I never seem to be that impressed with a 'higher end' waterproof remover. It did do it's job, sometimes better than other days. But my issue is that it wasn't even on waterproof mascara, it was just on regular suborn stuff and it would have issues taking it off. So it worked, it took sometime, it didn't leave a super oily residue around my eye (bonus) but I wouldn't spend the money for it, it's a great little perk.