This is my absolute favorite eyeliner for the waterline. I have the color "tiger's eye" and I'm not sure what's so special about it, it's just the perfect color. Normally, liner on the waterline makes my light brown eyes looks small and beady. But this color really makes my eyes stand out. I love the formula of this liner -- it isn't as long wearing as some other liners, but it's decent, and the texture is certainly very smooth and creamy. I would totally recommend this and can't wait to try the other colors.

I got this in Topaz after seeing it on Lauren Conrad's Beauty Department. I love love love the color and smoothness but it did not stay on my waterline for more than an hour. I don't want to pay a lot of money for an eyeliner that I have to reapply constantly. I'm pretty disappointed.

I use this every day, and can't believe I am the first to review it.
It is so creamy. I use an angled eyeliner brush to apply it, just like a fluidliner. It is also great if you want to smudge it.
This liner is amazing on the water line, but the only thing I would not recommend it for is hooded eyelids.
I have Onyx black, and I love love love it.