I love this liner. Its the ONLY eyeliner that has worked for my oily lids. Its the best!

I love this eye liner! Although it is a bit pricey, it works extremely well. I have this in Stingray, which is a very Black color. It is a thin, automatic eye liner - very user-friendly. When I first looked at it, I thought it was ironic that it was a "smudge stick" that was waterproof. But it's true! Work quickly if you want to smudge it, because once it sets, which is very fast, it will not budge! I use it to line my upper waterline, and it stays there all day! When I smile/laugh too much, however, it smudges a bit onto my lower lid. Overall, a great product!