True to its name!

My eyes can get super watery, especially during allergy season, so as soon as they begin to act up, I switch to this eyeliner. This is one of the only waterproof eyeliners that I've tried that is actually true to its claim! I love that when I use this, I don't have to worry about having black tear stains down the sides of my cheeks. The only thing that could make this better was if they switched to a calligraphy style brush tip instead of the felt tip, but that's just personal preference and won't stop me from repurchasing!

Good intensity and staying power

I just recently purchased this liner after years of using the Kat Von D liner in trooper. I find this formula has a truer black colour and no shine to it. It only loses a star for me since it has a tendency to bleed slightly if you aren't speedy enough with your application. Otherwise it would be a holy grail for those like me with oily skin and oily lids.

awesome

This is a great, precise liquid liner. The pen tip made it easy to get a winged liner, and it stayed on my oily lids for the whole day. The only issue I had was that the pen tip split and frayed easily.

Undecided

Stila stay all day waterproof mascara formula is good it actually stays in place even if you go to the pool. However the applicator is a little bit too thin for my personal taste, it takes a couple of times to get use to it. You might need to apply 2 or 3 layers of it to achieve the desired thickness.