I really liked this liner the first time I bought it. It lasted me quite a while and didn't dry out. It glides on very smoothly and stays put all day. My only problem with this is that it has a shine to it. I might still buy it the next time because it's so easy to use and works well but if there's a matte alternative, I'd definitely want to try that.

I wanted to like this liner, and it had some great reviews. My issue was the felt tip started fraying after only a week! Once that happened, I had a hard time getting a nice clean line. This is a department store product, and I expected better quality.

This was a really good eyeliner. It was great at first, when the ink was dark and full black, but as I've used it over the course of 2 months it has become less black - more thin, giving it a more greay appearance.
But in the first few uses- it was amazing. Bold, can make thin lines, easy to apply.

I have tried a lot of eyeliners and this one tops the charts glides on smooth and stays a long time and does not smudge as long as you let it set.

Good eyeliner it was my go to for a while, the only downside about it is thy I found that it dries out faster than other eyeliners. I purchased this more than once so the fact that it dried out didn't bother me because all products eventually dry out !

My HG eyeliner is Kat Von D's tattoo liner, but this is a close second. Great colour payoff and the fine tip makes it easy to do a cat eye!

I love this liner! It makes applying liquid liner so easy because it goes on so smoothly. I will say that the black liner goes on more smoothly than the brown liner though. I would definitely purchase the black loner again, not sure about the brown one though.

Love this product! I had a friend tell me about this and I'm so glad I gave it a try! So nice and precise. Easy to use and stays where you put it! It really does have all day wear ability. It makes your eye look professionally done. I must have for every Lady out there!!

this glides on smooth as silk. it stays all day. worth every penny

This product glides onto your eyelids very smoothly but after a few weeks of using it, the felt too starts wearing down and starts to bleed. This eyeliner though stays on all day and leaves your eyes with crisp and smooth lines.