I have the oiliest eyelids and every eyeliner that i have used get's smudged instantly! Using this eyeliner gets the job done and it stays all day!

Great liner, makes great wings! Glides on easily and does not crap out half way through drawing on your wings.

when using this eyeliner one has to make sure that the skin is clean and that it is not oily.

I forgot my eyeliner at home this weekend and had to borrow this off a friend. I had to glide it back and forth several times to see anything come out. It also feels like literally putting a marker to my face. Not a big fan, would rather use a liquid liner than a marker type.

What can I say about my fav eyeliner. I have greasy lids..REALLY greasy lids. This eyeliner STAYED!!!! No racoon eyes , no smudging. For sure if you have greasy lids , or need a liner to stay all day, this is for you!!!!

I just tried this for the first time just the other day. I had a bad sty infection on my left eye and it left a scar on my bottom waterline. I've been searching for something that will not fade on the tiny scar and this worked!!! So you can imagine how much I love this!!! It does not smudge and it lasts!!!

I cannot live without eyeliner. Let's just say that if I could choose only one cosmetic item, it would be eyeliner. Liquid eyeliner can be hard to apply but when I tried Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, not only was it easy to apply but it did what eyeliner should! Stila Stay All Day, stayed all day! AND it did not smudge! Love it!

I LOVE THIS LINER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The tip makes it super easy to work with and I can almost always get the perfect cat-eye with it... (It's typically operator error when one tries to apply liquid eyeliner after drinking a bottle of wine).
It stayed on all day and was pretty easy to remove with a cleansing oil.
I have already repurchased and plan on continuing to repurchase.

It was a little hard to use. I couldn't get it to come on fluidly. When it does start to wear off, it comes off in blotches, so that it looked like I missed some spots when I put it on. I wanted to like it, but I didn't.

Doesn't budge! Good pigmentation (I have it in "Dark Brown") and very easy to apply. Tip stays sharp for a precise line. This was my first ever liquid liner.