No thank you

I liked this eyeliner for about a week and then it started drying out and isn’t bold enough for me, I wouldn’t buy it again as I found better ones since I bought this one. I’m not impressed with stila products 😪 and it’s way too expensive for the quality

Goes on very smooth

Really easy to apply and lasts all day with no flaking etc. However I find when I use this that my eyeliner always ends up much thicker than I had wanted. Great quality but I would rather a thinner tip!

Not for oily eyelids

Pros:
Waterproof
Super smooth
Very deep black colour
Easy to apply and remove

Cons:
Will smudge if eyelids are oily
Expensive

I bought this eyeliner due to rave reviews claiming that my greasy eyelids won't smudge it at all, but I find that wearing it for 8+ hours will make it smudge at the tips especially if I do a winged look.

definitely stays all day

I purchased this due to a recommendation from my friends and now this eyeliner is definitely my favorite! It works as promised, and stays put all day. I tend to get oily eyelids but the product dries quick and doesn't rub off, which is great. It's pigmented and gets the job done in one stroke, very nice application! Would for sure recommend!!

Very disappointing

So many ladies swear by the Stila Liquid Eyeliner pens but I was extremely disappointed even returning the first one as defective to Sephora and getting a replacement. The applicator tip never got saturated enough for a crisp line, causing it to look patchy and uneven pigmentation. I am a regular liquid eye liner wearing for years and this one really failed to impress me. The felt tip was always dry and the pen seemed to run dry in under a month. I won't be buying Stila liquid eyeliner pens again.

Le meilleur liner EVER

Avec tous les liners que j'ai essayé. Voici le seul qui ne coule pas!!! Jamais!!! La ligne est parfaite et reste en place toute la journée. Je l'ADORE!!!

Worth every penny

I got this eyeliner as a free sample in a mascara sample kit and I could not get enough of it. The eyeliner is super black, matte and smudge proof. The pen is easy to use to create a flawless wing and it will not budge all day. This is the holy grail of eyeliners and has replaced my Kat Von D tattoo liner hands down

Eyeliner that stays all day

Have been looking for a good eyeliner that will stay on all day long. This definitely does the job. It goes on easy with no pressure and leaves a lovely defined line under the eye. Definitely worth spending the money to buy

<3 <3 <3

It feels redundent posting this review.. As anyone who has used the Stila Stay All Day Eyeliner knows it is THE ONE AND ONLY!

Seriously, as someone who is the most basic with their makeup and has been wearing eyeliner since the age of 14, this one takes the gold.

I have literally tried every single liquid eyeliner out there and none of them stand a chance against this one (Even Kat Von D, sorry girl).

If there is a better one out there, I am begging you to prove me wrong.. This one will keep being my holy grail until the end <3

Effective but expensive

I love this product, I've been using it for years and have noticed the price slowly increasing year over year in my area but nothing else has ever compared.
I love the shape of this (it's almost marker-like) because it makes application very easy, and the product is long lasting and the colour is very rich (I use "intense black"). I have walked around in the rain multiple times with this eyeliner and it's held up wonderfully, but it does eventually wear off if I rub my eyes a lot.