Intense Labradorite

I had heard a lot about Stila and wanted to try something of their’s so this was my first purchase. I wanted to use something other than black as I am always using black eye liner. This has a dark grey shimmer to it and as a woman of a certain age feels that wearing shimmer and glitter should be subtle. This is easy to apply and you can create either a thin line or a thick liner. The shape of the tip helps create a great flick if that’s how you want to wear your eyeliner. If like me you suffer from Dry Eye and/or MGD unfortunately this product contains some of the nasties that you have to avoid as they can cause irritation.

Not for oily eyelids

Pros:
Waterproof
Super smooth
Very deep black colour
Easy to apply and remove

Cons:
Will smudge if eyelids are oily
Expensive

I bought this eyeliner due to rave reviews claiming that my greasy eyelids won't smudge it at all, but I find that wearing it for 8+ hours will make it smudge at the tips especially if I do a winged look.

Bloody mess

At first I really liked this liner. It applied super easily and lasted quite a long time. But eventually the tip started to fail and the product started bleeding everywhere. This was the same pen too. I wanted to love it and have it be my holy grail, but I like brush tips WAY more than felt tips.

I have oily skin, and the "stay all day" liner did not live up to its name for me. I had to re-apply/fix many times throughout the day because it would smudge and give me raccoon eyes.

Many people love this eyeliner for its ability to last a long time, but for me this did not work at all. It smudged and gave me "panda eyes" in no time flat. Granted, I have the perfect storm of conditions (oily, hooded eyelids) to challenge any eyeliner's ability to last more than 2 hours, but I have definitely found a few that will do much better than this one, especially for the price.

This was one of the first pen liquid eye liners I purchased. I still use it today, and do like it, but I might not repurchase it when I run out, simply because I find there are other ones out there that work better and last longer that don't cost as much as this one does. I doesn't exactly stay all day for me. The brush works well and you can get thin or thick lines. If I had no access to other types of eye liners (such as Asian brands), then I would consider repurchasing this.

I expected it to literally stay all day but even with primer my lids are quite oily and it does come out slowly throughout the day. the one thing I do like is the precision of the felt tip!

This product didn't work out for me. It was a regular eyeliner. It didn't meet up to its hype unfortunately.

I wanted to like this liner, and it had some great reviews. My issue was the felt tip started fraying after only a week! Once that happened, I had a hard time getting a nice clean line. This is a department store product, and I expected better quality.

This product glides onto your eyelids very smoothly but after a few weeks of using it, the felt too starts wearing down and starts to bleed. This eyeliner though stays on all day and leaves your eyes with crisp and smooth lines.