I love butter lipstick and Tarte's brand is great - it leaves lips feeling smooth and soft. My only complaint would be that it's not very long-lasting so you have to re-apply it through the day.

I really, REALLY wanted to love these lipsticks when I ordered them online. I have four shades total. The colours are beautiful and they are very pigmented but the staying power is not great and the packaging is AWFUL! The tube is made of cardboard and can easily be damaged. I have never seen a cardboard tube on a lipstick before and just found it strangem. I threw one in my purse and the top of the tube got crushed because it is so delicate! I dont think I'll be using these too often as I can't take them anywhere with me and I won't be buying any more. Pretty disappointed and wish I didnt buy 4 at once before seeing them in person.