I Found this product be useless. It is 2 steps. The "ready set camera" mascara felt great going on, the formula was smooth and looked great alone, then the second step was the the black fibers wand. They all fall on your face and stick to your cheeks, the fibers get in your eyes and irritate them. I found it clumpy. I did not like this. I would recommend the white fibre wand that comes with competition. Two Faced in Sephora. Works great!