I didn't know how to really pick what shade I wanted, as I'm light skinned with dark brown eyebrows and want/need cool toned eyebrow pencil. I got the fair-light. All around I was disappointed in the pencil, it just fell apart on the second day and wasn't worth trying to fix. I was interested in the angle slanted pencil, it's thinner than the Smashbox one, but the pencil broke and it wouldn't stay in the slot. The color wasn't the best match, little red undertones in it, but not a lot, but I was more really disappointed in how little product was actually in the pencil. The spolie part was nice, stiff and easily brushed out my eyebrow hairs and product. But then the underscoring concealer was another flop. The sponge tip almost picked up to much product, it didn't blend on the skin, was caky, fell all over the place... just not for me.