I'm not going to lie, this is a nice product. I bought it in a sample size and it lasted for a surprisingly long time. It is refreshing and moisturizing. However, I don't find it to be groundbreaking or anything new in terms of eye treatments - and I didn't notice a big difference when using it, even compared to just using an all-over face moisturizer as my "eye treatment".

This is the only eye cream that I have tried so far that I have used the longest (3 months or so) without experiencing any issues.

I like Tart's packaging, only down side is it's not very hygienic, but not a big deal as I always wash my hands before handling products. Like most eye creams, Tarte's eye cream is creamy and light. I found it to be hydrating (without any greasy residue), doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes, it does brighten my under eyes somewhat (my dark circles aren't too bad but it is hard to see dramatic changes). As for the firming properties, I cannot verify that claim as my eye area is still quite firm and mostly line free.

For $46, this eye cream is quite nice. And since it contains mango, rice bran and coconut, it's definitely a nice change from the usual ingredients used in other eye creams. This one might be a keeper as it doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. However, I am still on the lookout for the perfect eye cream. While this product is quite close to being the perfect eye cream for me, it's still missing something.