I didn't give it five star because I expect it to be better then this. I do like this product but like everything products there is pros and cons.

The only thing I didn't like about it is it smudges. So don't every do this on your waterline.

The Pros..
After it smudges it actually stays on very long so is good if you are doing smoky eyes.
It is very creamy so you don't have to press too hard on your eyelid.

I was hoping I found an eyeliner pencil that can go on my waterline but I guess I have to keep shopping around...

Hands down the best eyeliners on the planet. I've tried many and urban decay makes such an amazing product. The colors are fantastic and the wearability is amazing!

Great eye Pencil!! It last all night, to the point where its almost a pain to remove.

I purchased this product in purple and black, I love both. They glide on easily and last all day. The pigment is great. The purple has become part of my daily routine.

Want a super smoth liner with no smudging? Look no further! I love urban decay and they nailed it with this liner

love love love this! it glides on like a dream! the black is very very black!

now the only down-side is the price. you can get almost the same product from the Sephora brand without a huge loss in quality for half the price.

Awesome eye liner that doesn't hurt to apply and stays on for a long time without smudging.

Great pigmentation and color pay off. Stays on and looks great all day. Smooth application and great color selection! Have tried the purple and black so far and intend to buy more in the future.

I have this eyeliner and I am madly in love! No fall-out and it always stays all day long.

I like them. More for waterline. Very creamy. Sometimes too soft