Really nice bronze liquid liner with metallic flecks. Very flattering on my skin tone. But it's definitely not as waterproof as I was expecting. It doesn't smear or run if my eyes well up, it just kind of disappears or wears off around the outer corners of my eyes. (I don't know where it goes!) Easy to touch up though so nbd. I like the long handle because it's easy to control. The tip is a really fine cluster of bristles as opposed to the felt tip I was expecting. I kind of wish that every liquid liner had this type of brush to be honest, because I feel like it deposits the product more evenly and is fine enough to make a super sharp flick.

Great eyeliner! The brush is super thin and little, which makes it easy to use each time! Very black and dark, non streaky, fast drying, matte and beautiful! Love! The best liquid eye liner I've ever used, will for sure buy again :) 9/10.

This eyeliner has a magnificent glide when applying it. I usually love most Urban Decay products, however this fell short a bit. It gets flaky quickly and crumbles easily. This eyeliner also stings more than most when you get a bit of it in your eye. It's no winner but not the worst I have used either.

The best waterproof liquid liner. Stays on perfectly, washes off easily. I got Black, and it is super solid and easy to apply. Will be using this liquid liner as a staple in my everyday makeup.

I got this in my ipsy bag and loved it, it lasts soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo long almost hard to get off its unreal!

I have almost every color. They are rich in color, stays on all day & won't fade or smear. I love the look of liquid liners on the top of my lash line.

I love using liquid eyeliner. I found this product quite effective, the eyeliner was very bold and dark in colour. I liked the brush as well. The only complaint was that I felt that it was not very water proof because the makeup would fall.

I have this in a glittery dark purple shade. The applicator is easy to use. I was worried that it would only be suitable for nighttime but the glitter is subtle enough that I can wear it to work. It looks striking when I'm out in the sun though!

Not as good as the Stila one but it works really well and doesn't smudge!

Best eyeliner available. It's a bit pricey but it stays on all day for me, takes a lot to take off and it does not run or smear at all.