Expected more

I got a sample size. It did lengthen my lashes, but not much and did some what separate them as well. But didn't see any curling, there is a little flakiness.

Urban decay is better than this

I got this product in an Urban Decay surprise box. This might be the only UD product that I've ever been disappointed in. The formula was on the dry side and flaked quite quickly (plus I got some of the flakes in my eye which was painful). Unfortunately this product lived up to its name.

Long defined lashes

I love this mascara. I particularly love the length and definition.
I would say the application process of the product can take time as the lashes are susceptible to sticking together and you can get excess. I would recommend a primer lash product being applied before hand.
The product is long lasting.

Didn't live up to its promises.

I was in a hurry to go out and since I finished the tube of mascara I have been using recently using I had to pick another one quickly. I chose Urban Decay TroubleMaker mascara and was extremely disappointed. It didn't give me any length or volume whatsoever. All it seemed to do was darken my lashes. I applied three coats like I usually do and I was almost better off wearing no mascara. I did not have any trouble with clumping or flaking like other reviewers even though the weather has been very hot and humid. I absolutely love Urban Decay eye-shadow but this mascara was a no win for me. I am very happy that I received this in a monthly beauty box subscription because if I paid full price for this I would be very unhappy. Even drug store brands have impressed me more than this one. I will definitely stick to my Clinique High Impact mascara for my no makeup makeup days and my Benefit Rollerlash or Benefit Bad Gal Bang for when I really want to lengthen and curl my lashes.

pretty good!

Did what it was supposed to. Wasn’t mind blowing. Smelt like something on fire, not pleasant. Flaked off a lot during the day but was manageable. OK experience.

Amazing

I would and have been purchasing this mascara for about 2 years now, it's lengthening and volumizing, excellent! It make my eyelashes look amazing, if there was one thing I always need in my makeup bag, its this mascara!

Makes the eyes pop

This is amazing mascara. Made the eyes pop. I love it. I got asked where my lashes fake. I used the black. This is great stuff. Will be buying more. 💙💙💙

Great Mascara!

I am quite impressed with this mascara wand! The bristles are separated and long so that it keeps your eyelashes defined and easily gets rid of any clumps. Sometimes I get some mascara on my eyelids because the bristles are quite long though, but it's okay if I'm wearing eyeliner which I do most of the time. I found it very easy to build up the mascara without it being too clumpy. I recommend wiggling the brush as you apply rather than just brushing up, to get the best use out of the mascara. And use an eyelash curler!

Best Mascara

I absolutely love this mascara, not only does it lengthen my lashes, it volumizes them, It holds the curl all day long. It is the only mascara that doesn't end up under my eyes after a couple of hours. I have used so many mascaras, none of them compare to this one, it truly is the best.

Expensive, but one of my favourite mascaras ever

Okay I know a lot of the reviews for this mascara are lacklustre, so I was hesitant, but I received a sample with a promo code from Sephora and I’ll be buying the full sized product, hands down. This mascara is incredible. HOWEVER, I have long natural lashes, so does this make a difference? Perhaps. The wand’s bristles remind me of a cactus, almost, with the number of bristles and how “sharp” the bristles look. But I find the bristles really separate my lashes, and really prevent clumping, which is a huge issue with many mascaras that I’ve tried in the past (I have somewhat thick lashes - they clump easily). This mascara makes my eyelashes look so long and full, I can actually see my lashes when I look up. My eyes really pop with this mascara, to the point where I won’t wear eyeliner because the mascara competes with the liner and I just don’t need the liner to make my eyes look incredible. Honest and truly, I adore this mascara so so so much - I find applying it is very easy, you have plenty of product on the wand, and 3-4 swipes of the brush per eye is enough to make my eyes stand out from across the room. I’ve had people ask me what mascara I use because of how long my lashes look. If you can find a sample, I would really recommend giving it a try and not being swayed by some of the negative reviews!