Didn't live up to its promises.

I was in a hurry to go out and since I finished the tube of mascara I have been using recently using I had to pick another one quickly. I chose Urban Decay TroubleMaker mascara and was extremely disappointed. It didn't give me any length or volume whatsoever. All it seemed to do was darken my lashes. I applied three coats like I usually do and I was almost better off wearing no mascara. I did not have any trouble with clumping or flaking like other reviewers even though the weather has been very hot and humid. I absolutely love Urban Decay eye-shadow but this mascara was a no win for me. I am very happy that I received this in a monthly beauty box subscription because if I paid full price for this I would be very unhappy. Even drug store brands have impressed me more than this one. I will definitely stick to my Clinique High Impact mascara for my no makeup makeup days and my Benefit Rollerlash or Benefit Bad Gal Bang for when I really want to lengthen and curl my lashes.

pretty good!

Did what it was supposed to. Wasn’t mind blowing. Smelt like something on fire, not pleasant. Flaked off a lot during the day but was manageable. OK experience.

Not a fav

I got sent a sample of this mascara to try. And I absolutely love UD but I was so disappointed with this mascara. It made my lashes clumpy. I believe it could have been effective paired with another mascara but I want a mascara that is great as a stand alone.

Nothing special

I wasn't crazy about this mascara. I found it didn't make my lashes look volumized or long. It would definitely not be worth the price point. It smells really weird too.

Meh.

I really wanted to like this mascara as i love Urban Decay. While it works for other people, it just doesn't work for me. I have straight lashes and this mascara doesn't help volumize my lashes like other mascaras, for example- Too Faced BTS.

Didn't have much luck

Urban Decay sent me a sample size of this and I was really hoping to love it ... The bristles remind me of the Benefit They're Real, but the formula seems drier, so the bristles really poke my eyes (I have short asian lashes, so I need to take it to the very base to apply mascara. Also, I find it very hard to build up volume because bristles comb them out so well

Not impressed

I received this product tp test. I have to say I was rather disappointed. The size made it difficult to even apply the mascara properly. The mascara it self clumped and made didn't go on evenly
I probably won't try again

Okay mascara

I expected more from this mascara based on the claims. My lashes were longer but not as much as advertised. I liked the big brush though. The mascara went on smooth but dried too fast to do multiple coats. It did not irritate my eyes and washed off fairly easily at the end of the day. I would use this again because it is an okay mascara but don't expect great results.

Hurts

This mascara works okay, not the best. The worst part is the lash applicator is so pointy that it hurts when it goes on :( The product isnt that thick and only provides length and separation, with no volume or thickness

Not the greatest

I think this mascara was over hyped. I currently use the urban decay perversion mascara so I was so excited to try the new troublemaker mascara. I received a free sample from urban decay and it was ok, not the greatest. It actually ran and I had it smeared under my eyes. I will be sticking to the pervision mascara.