I bought these treats at my local petstore and my dogs loved them. They smell pretty good upon opening have a resealable zipper packaging which is needed because I forgot to close them one day and 3 days later when I reached for another piece, the tenders were rock hard! These already come in the package as dehydrated tenders but it was still flexible. So do not forget to close the top on these if you buy them, as with any other food that comes with a resealable zipper, use them!