Pricy, but works well

Works as well as a conventional pencil eyeliner, without questionable ingredients. Not too soft that it smudges all over, not too hard that it's a struggle to use, stays on throughout the day. A little pricy, however.

I am sort of on the fence about this eyeliner. Love the packaging, looks very sleek and clean. Also love that they are all-natural and free of harsh chemicals and that it doesn't irritate my eyes. The black colour is nice and dark and goes on very smooth. However, I am finding that in the hotter weather it wears off pretty fast and I get really smudgy-looking eyes. Especially days where I am outside for a while or even on a patio.

It stays really well as long as it's not muggy out, or if i'm in spending the day in class or at the office. I suppose it is better to use if you are able to do touch-ups a couple times a day, or if you are not out in the heat, but not great if you are busy and can't be bothered. Sad to say the conventional liner I used before this has better staying power.

Will probably be trying a different 'green' eyeliner when this one runs out. But will still recommend it for anyone looking to make the switch to cleaner products, as it still does the job decently and is a better choice overall above any drug store ones!