This pencil is far too cheaply made and it scratches. It does not sharpen properly and it is very rough on the eye. In fact, after the first few tries, I stopped using it around my eyes and now just dab a spot on my eyebrows on rare occasions. It does a fair job when using it to fill eyebrow spots.
I bought this liner on the same day in two colors (601A - Baby's Got Black & 603A Simma Brown) more than a year ago and both pencils are still pretty tall. They now stay in my makeup case to remind me to not buy again.
I do no recommend this product for eyes. I do (slightly) recommend it to be used sparingly on brows, if you have nothing else and only when needed.