I was not satisfied with this product, the price was cheap and so was the brush, I think the problem with this product is the brush that it comes with because it did not apply great and gave no plumping action. It is can be an okay mascara if you use an a better mascara brush that you may have on hand. I do not recommend it.

I bought this in a pinch and hate it. It doesn't clump but it flakes off and I hate it.