Not for me

After using this only once I had to remove it promptly. I had an allergic reaction that resulted in extremely itchy, red eyes. I had a moderate dermatitis after use. I didn’t find the overall effectiveness of the product to be very good . My lashes didn’t seem any more curled or defined . Packaging was pretty and overall ease of use was good. However due to the reaction I can’t give a fully detailed review.

it isn't a good mascara, especially waterproof one

I adore waterproof mascaras that work well. They have to set to a consistency that doesn't stay wet, it has to dry down. So, the lashes aren't sticky and wont stick together (and things like pet hair don't stick to it). They also have to be waterproof, and not smear or smudge. They also shouldn't dry to a crumble texture and flake off all day. If I rub my eye, it should stay put. Finally they have to be waterproof when exposed to water. This mascara hits two of those marks, it dose not crumble and if you rub it wont smudge, but it will make all your lashes become one clump. It almost never sets, so it remains smearible, the lashes will clump and stick together, Even while applying it my lashes clumped up. If I apply it sparingly, it does nothing for pigment or length. It really is just a poor mascara. I have nothing positive to say about it at all. I am so disapointed.