Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 1574

GOSH Forever Eye Shadow Stick

234 reviews

This pencil is so usefull when you’re going out and want to get ready quickly,I love this product because its look good on my skin tone I also use it as a highlighter which works well too.
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Eyeshadow Quad

183 reviews

This product glides on like butter, super blendable and highly pigmented. I would recommend you buy this over any over priced shadow. These work best compared to all those out there.
Maybelline Eye Studio Color Tattoo 24HR Cream Gel Eye Shadow

175 reviews

I recently had laser eye surgery which was amazing but i found that i struggled to wear powder eye shadow afterwards as it would irritate my eyes. Discovering this cream eyeshadow was a revelation. It glides on easily and gives a great pop of colour. It doesnt settle into lines...
MAC Cosmetics Paint Pots

131 reviews

I have Paint Pot from MAC in the shade Vintage Selection and I use this everyday, as a base for my other powder eye-shadows. Putting Paint Pot underneath as a base locks on my make-up look and as Vintage Selection has a soft shimmer it could even be worn on it's own as a...
L'Oreal Paris HIP High Intensity Pigments Eye Shadow Duo

116 reviews

I love majority of the colors from this line and I am impressed by the intensity of these 2 colors. I pair this with other colors for a simple day look. I love l'oreal eye shadows!!!
Tarte Tease Palette

65 reviews

I bought this for a trip as it was a small palette and it didn’t take up too much space. I had high expectations for this one. But it wasn’t as good as I expected. The shadow didn’t last long and it didn’t look very good. I was just disappointed with it since I have...
Morphe 3502 eyeshadow palette

45 reviews

I loved this one. It's easy to apply and blend in good. I would buy it again because it's gorgeous and natural. Morphe is a beautiful and successful brand. I would literally buy anything from there.
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Amber Rush

51 reviews

I'd describe this Infallible eyeshadow as a long lasting cream to powder formula I used to like the smoky silver shade but they must have discontinued this in the UK as I can no longer see it in any stores.
LA Colors Mad4U Eyeshadow

1 review

I bought the LA colors Mad4U Eyeshadow in C37245 Cherry Tarte for $1,70 at the Dollar tree. It has 4 eyeshadows in a 0.15 OZ package. I like it. The color goes on super well, has some pigment. It has a mix of matte and shimmer shades. It looks nice with my navy eyes, and fair...
jeffree star blood sugar palette

35 reviews

The pigmentation is amazing in this palette! Don't forget to put a base first otherwise some color with stay .. blend easily, almost no fall out , everything I want in a palette but for real the pigmentation is the reason I love Jeffree star palette.
L.A. Colors Website

1 review

I have tried eyeshadow palettes from the L.A. Colors brand and have liked them. I went on their website and it contains even more products. They have lip and cheek products, nail products, eyelash Products, brow products, nail polish, lip balm, shadow sticks, and twist up...
L.A. Colours 6 Color Eyeshadow Palette in Lucky

1 review

I bought the Lucky 6 shade Eyeshadow Palette in the L.A. Colors brand. It is a small compact sized palette perfect for fitting in a purse. It is the 0.14 OZ weight palette. It goes on soft. There is lots of shimmer. I like that it has some warm and cool toned greens, a...
Le Mercerie favorite Essentials Collection Nude Smoky Shimmery Eyeshadow with Applicator

1 review

I bought the Le Mercerie Favorite Essentials Collection Nude Smoky Shimmery Eyeshadow Palette with Applicator from the Dollar Tree Canada for $1.70. It is well worth it. I like how soft it applies and the shimmery effect it has on the eyelids and surrounding areas. It has some...
Santee Ultimate Nude Collection Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

I bought the Santee Ultimate Nude Collection Eyeshadow Palette. I have been using it for over a year now, and it goes on beautifully. It has warm shades of orange. I like it best in the fall time, and use it any time of year. The colours are like pumpkin spice or cinnamon toast...
L.A. Colors Lip Duo in the color Vibe, a bright Purple Color

1 review

I bought the L. A. Colors lip Duo, lipstick. It is dual sided makeup product. It has a lipgloss on one end and a lipstick on the other. I bought the 0.05 FL Oz size for $1.70 at the Dollartree. There are many other shade options of the same brand at the store. The one I bought...
Urban Decay Electric Palette

38 reviews

Love! (Need I say more?) Loooooveeee For everything and anything; Performing Artistry Everyday fun Subtle and sweet Loving and lustrous I could go on, But I'm going to go play Elsa now so.... Try it! 💜
Make-up Revolution MOUSSE Revolution cream eye-shadow

1 review

We've seen the revival of a few Y2K beauty trends and cream eye shadows are enjoying a moment. Mousse Revolution's air whipped formula is light as air so I never feel like I have anything on my eyelids, plus this is a formula easy to apply, blend and work with either using your...
CoverGirl Eye Enhancers 760 Tapestry Taupe

1 review

I love these single shadows from CoverGirl, with this shade being my #1 favourite. It's a soft, taupe with silver shimmer. A classy and flattering colour. Perfect as a 'one and done' shadow, for a quick but cute eyelook.
Naked Smokey Palette

39 reviews

Love this palette!!! The colors are so vibrant. I don't have to worry about them smudging or creasing. Would definitely recommend this product. Its a must have.
NYX Professional Makeup Hot Singles Eyeshadow

74 reviews

NYX mono eye shadows are similar to MAC's single eye shadows, cute, adorable pots of blendable powder shadow, some are shimmer, some matte, some a pearlescent or frost effect and all the colours are highly pigmented with high definition colour pay off, you get a good hit of...