Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
341-360 of 1574

MUA Professional 6 Shade Palette Rusted Wonders

1 review

I bought this product because I wanted new glittery eye shadow. The palette is really pigmented which I was really shocked because its really cheap. Like £3.50. I love it and its lasted really long considering I use it all the time.
Violet Voss Ride or Die

1 review

This palette is absolutely amazing. The shadows are soft, blendable, buildable and pigmented. These really blend together so effortlessly. This has been one of my favorites lately.
Revolution Pro HD Amplified 35 Palette: Neutrals Warm

2 reviews

Revolution is my go to brand for eyeshadows! This pallet has so many different combinations it’s amazing, they are really pigmented, and easy to blend using their blending brush, so many different looks, so little time!
ciate London x Chloe Morello

4 reviews

Such a stunning palette. The colors are stunning especially the shimmers. I bought it when it was on sale at Sephora and I haven't regretted it once. The colors blend like a dream. And Chloe Morello is one of my favorite YouTubers!
Stila Eyeshadow - Kitten

16 reviews

Kitten by Stila is in everyones makeup bag. It is such a pretty color and so versitile. It can be used as a all over lid color, a highlight color, or a blender. It wears well and is overall amazing. A definte staple in my bag.
Tarte pinapple of my eye palette

1 review

Bought this at Sephora cause I liked the colours and IHOP early don’t reach for it. It comes with 2 blushes a bronzer that is really deep in colour and a highlighter. The eyeshadows have a coconut smell which I like but I don’t reach for it anymore
NAKED COSMETICS Mother Nature #06

4 reviews

I got this in my beauty subscription bag. It is a really pretty shimmery beige/nude/gold kinda shade in person. Single shadow, so it takes up a bit of room unless you take it out of its casing. It worked decent. Doesn’t stay on all day without primer, but works for a few...
QUO COUTURE EYE SHADOW DUO BEYOND BLISS

1 review

I purchased this on sale at Shoppers Drug Mart. I like a lot of Quo products but this eye shadow is basically useless unless you're using it as a light highlighter. The shades look nice but when applied they do not look the same at all, barely pigmented, basically just a light...
GWA Aphrodite Palette

2 reviews

I wasn't expecting much for the price, but I had to give it a go. I was absolutely blown away by the quality and pigment. It was better than some higher end brands. I have since bought more pallets from this company and they all meet that high level of quality. Amazing.
theBalm Voyage Vol. 2 Eyeshadow in Kuwakaribisha

5 reviews

This was my first product I've ever tried from the balm cosmetics. I received it in my ipsy bag and I enjoy it very well to put a little but of highlight in my inner corner when I do a look with eyeshadow.
Avon 2 Pod Smokey Eyeshadow

5 reviews

Very good value for money, as it is very pigmented and packs on to you eye with or without primer with ease. This is something that has become a staple in my day to day beauty bag
Tarte Tartlette Tease eye shadow palette

8 reviews

One of my first expensive palette i ever bought! And i love it. It’s super pigmented and it smells amazing. Know another palette that smells like chocolate? Me neither? I will definitely buy it again even if it’s just to smell it !
L’Oréal Infallible Nudist Eyeshadow Paint

1 review

I have this in the Champagne 205 shade. I’m in love with it. I use it not for eyeshadow (yet) I use it to highlight the inner duck of my eye area. It stays for a long time
Morphe Eyeshadow Palettes

18 reviews

Morphe is literally a luxury quality palette but 10x more affordable. It’s very pigmented, and there is very little to basically no fall out. I would definitely recommend. I have 2 palettes and I love them
Colourpop pressed eyeshadow

4 reviews

I love their eyeshadow palettes the pigmentation is amazing the glitter stays on without glue it’s affordable and there’s so many different types of eyeshadow palette’s to choose from it’s amazing
ELF Studio Baked Eyeshadow Trio

8 reviews

The ELF Cosmetics baked eyeshadow trio is one of my go to products. The colors are so beautiful and pigmented. They last for a long time and go on so smoothly.
Dirty Little Secret Cosmetics Eyeshadow in Sangria

2 reviews

Absolutely beautiful colour
Stila Magnificent Metals Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow

8 reviews

I always wanted to have glitter pop on my eyelids and this is the easiest most effective way to do it. I love adding sparkle to amp any eye look. I love these !!!
Tarte treasure box collection

1 review

The Tarte treasure box is amazing it has 24 shadows, 2 bronzers, 2 blushes and highlighter. Not to mention comes with tarte mascara lights lashes I believe. Also a maybe matte lip paint by tarte and the sex kitten eye liner. It's pretty much your whole face in one collection...
QUO All-About-Eyes Palette

7 reviews

I felt the pigmentation is fabulous, all though I have not experimented with each of the 54 eyeshadow or the 12 eye liners I did however swatch each one, and was very impressed thus far. The colors vary in range from light to dark, matte to sparkle. I also know that reds and...