Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
401-420 of 1574

Maybelline New York Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads, Chai Latte

1 review

Whether going for the daily natural and glowing 5 minutes makeup, beachy vibes, or approaching to bold, flattering date-night look, Maybelline New York Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads always get my life covered.
L.A. Colors Expressions 12-Color Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

With world autism day around the corner, I bought the L.A Colors "supernatural" smokey palette with variations of blues. Today for world autism day I used the blues to make my autism awareness look. The palettes colors are VERY pigmented but have A LOT of fall off. I cant...
NYX happy birthday palette

1 review

I received this palette for free from Ulta for my birthday. I would describe this as being autumn in an eyeshadow palette. My favorite color is a bright orange. I definitely see myself using this many times this season.
theBalm Cosmetics The Balm Voyage Vol. 2 eyeshadow

2 reviews

I really like the shade of this eye shadow. The texture is good and is easy to apply. I really liked the product and I really recommend this product for everyone!
Makeup Geek sparklers and loose pigments

1 review

Makeupgeek.com was the first place that I bought proffessional makeup from. I ended buying this variety pack of what they call "sparklers and loose pigments". Also this variety pack is completely vegan so that's a bonus. I think their whole site is leaping bunny approved. I...
Tarte rainforest of the sea volume 2

2 reviews

Even though there are all shimmer colours in this pallette, I love it. One of my faves! I do find that there tends to be a lot of fall out with these colours though. Very dry shadow. Tip is to spray your brush with setting spray and then dip into your shadow! Love the mirror and...
Rival de Loop Diamond Eye Powder in Amethyst

1 review

I bought this pigment while traveling in Germany. It was cheap and it looked nice in the package. I don't own any purple pigments or eye shadows and thought it would be a good idea to try. I wasn't disappointed. Is a nice lilac color that compliments my hazel eye color nicely...
Eyetini Shadow Tint in Ambrosia

1 review

I love this cream/liquid shadow, Ambrosia is a great smokey purple color. They do call this an eye tint, however it is very opaque and more like a liquid shadow. They come in a lip gloss tube and you apply it using a regular doe foot applicator, the formula is very light moussy...
bh cosmetics by carli bybel

4 reviews

Out of all the palettes that I have, I KEEP coming back to this one. It works very well and I LOVE how it looks on my lids as well as my cheeks. I love the highlighters in this palette, they look so shimmery and pretty
CoverGirl Eye Shadow Palette

17 reviews

Great color and smooth feel with beautiful finished results! I used the palette for hazel eyes which compliments eye colour nicely! Great for every day use if you're a regular eyeshadow wearer. Good value!
Maybelline New York The City Mini Palette

1 review

I love all 5 (out of 9) City Mini palettes I have, truly beautiful high-pigmented and shimmering shades! Perfect for travel, fits in any purse and greatly versatile for creating many different looks. Creamy texture that stays put and comes in separate palettes for each season...
Pacifica Natural Mineral Eyeshadow Palette

3 reviews

Nice shades of eyeshadow, goes on smoothly, good pigmented, stays on pretty good as I have oily lids. Vegan. & cruelty-free After the near expiry date of 12month, I found mold on the shadow.
Too Faced Glitter Eye Bomb Palette

1 review

Always been a sucker for glitter, this palette is very beautiful and full of high quality coverage. You can start little to build more with still great consistency and coverage.
W7 In The Buff Lightly Toasted Eye Colour Palette

2 reviews

I scored this palette at winners a few months ago and it has easily become one of my favorite palettes. The colors are great and the shadow itself goes on and stays.
Wet n' wild Coloricon Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

I'm talking about the 10 pan palette like the comfort zone palette those ones are amazing, it's not that pigmented but they are buildable so you can make it look amazing ❤️
Real her play book 1

2 reviews

I love this real her 1 eyeshadow pallet. It has very beautiful shades. And is very pigmented and goes on like butter. It's so smooth and beautiful. I love it
tarte tarteist pro to go amazonian clay palette

4 reviews

I got this palette in a subscription beauty bag/box I receive and I pulled it out recently to take with us on our vacation. I have brown eyes and work at home wearing little makeup daily. I wanted to have a great palette to take with me so I could actually do my eyes up while...
Pixi by petra eye shadow palette in plum quartz

6 reviews

I found this hard to blend and all the dark colors look the same on the lid and I think its too glittery even though they do not look like that . Will not buy Pixi eye shadow again unless the formula changes.
Maybelline EyeStudio Eyeshadow Quad

1 review

Was really good eyeshadow. Good colour. I find it lasts all day but I do use an eyeshadow primer. For the value and what you get it is perfect. Great for daily wear so you are not using the expensive stuff all the time. Its a decent price and I find it on sale from time to time!
MUD fard a paupière

1 review

MUD existe depuis des années en Europe et est maintenant disponible en Amérique !!! Produits maquillage vraiment très abordables et la qualité est exceptionnelle !!! Pour le fard a paupière.. sec ou mouillé pour un regard plus intense ou simplement ligne d'eyeliner.. vous...