Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
461-480 of 1574

Annabelle Skinny Palettes

5 reviews

Toute mes ombres à paupières vienne de la pharmacie et je dois dire que coter qualité Annabelle les surpasse tous surtout les skinny palettes que je trouve absolument sublime. Les ombres poudre sont crémeuses et elle se fonde très bien et s'estompe à merveille. Elles...
L'Oreal Paris Cosmetics Colour Riche Monos Eyeshadow, Acro-Matte

1 review

Love this eye shadow! I do use a primer, as suggested. The shadow goes on smoothly and the many choices of colors offered is great. Would definitely buy again.
Maybelline New York Expert Wear Eyeshadow, Acid Rain

1 review

Good eye shadow. It'd not TOO noticeable, but it is enough to really make a difference in your eye make up. I really like this color for using with a few different looks. This variety of maybelline eye shadows have a nice amount of product in each container as well.
L'Oreal Paris Infallible 24Hr Eye Shadow, 756 Always Pearly Pink

1 review

This is a BEAUTIFUL, buttery, pigmented eye shadow that is just as good as many of my more expensive branded eye shadow pallets. It stays on my eyelids and blends well with other colors. This is a wonderful color for people with blue eyes to make their eye color pop! Highly...
MAC Eye Shadow Sticks

2 reviews

The Mac Pro Long wear Waterproof Color Stick is exactly what I have been searching for in an eye shadow! The colors are very vibrant and the formula delivers high def colors with good coverage in a single swipe. I am a senior lady and the jumbo pencil is effortless compared to...
Tarte Cosmetics Dont Quit Your Daydream Palette

1 review

This product is awesome!! The colors are super duper pigmented and they blend extremely well. Perfect for any time of year. Packaging is great as well.
Mary Kay Cream Eye Color

37 reviews

The colors look pretty on, but personally I preferred Mary Kay's pressed powder eye color much more. The cream felt too heavy on my eye and dried out quickly in the container, making it harder and harder to use until I had to throw it away. It looked good, it just wasn't what I...
Sephora Collection – Sunbleached Filter Palette

1 review

So I’m like 50/50 on this palette, I LOVE the lighter shades there’s lots of pigment, not patchy, not chalky & very little fall out, BUT when it comes to the darker shades, well.. They’re kind of awful. They lack pigment (especially using a brush, better blending with your...
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Extreme Shimmer Shadow & Liner Palette

3 reviews

I absolutely adore these palettes from physicians formula. They are compact, easy to blend and inexpensive. I like to wet my brush before applying the eyeshadow so that the color pops. Really beautiful palette and formula, highly recommended!
Real her play book

1 review

I'm really enjoying the shades in this palette. I find the shadows to be well pigmented and blend very easily. It's easy to build depth with these shadows. The shimmer in them is beautiful. It gives a nice sheen without tons of glitter falling all over your face. Negative, I do...
HIKARI Cream Pigment Eyeshadow in Envy

1 review

The product has a nice creamy texture that makes it easy to apply. Goes on a bit uneven/splotchy. The gold colour is pretty and looks nice with my hazel eye colour.
Urban Decay Jean-Michel Basquiat Tenant Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

I love this palette! The shadows are so pigmented and last all day. The colour selection is so pretty and really make the eyes pop. You can also hang this palette on the wall so it is also an art piece which is amazing! I would recommend getting this limited edition palette...
L'Oréal Paris Infallible 24 HR Eye Shadow

1 review

I can see the hype about these...they are beautiful and there are many great colours both bold and neutral. The pigmentation is comparable to that of their high end competitors. Ive only tried one - eternal sunshine, a yellow gold - and I was not dissapointed. I applied the...
L'Oreal Paris Colour Riche Eyeshadow 260 Incredible Grey

2 reviews

Great intense coverage. Definitely worth the money you pay. I don't have any complaints about this product, so no room for improvement for me personally. I like the dark colors better because I have brown eyes, but I tried lighter ones also, and they have the same intense...
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips All-in-1 Custom Nude Palette

2 reviews

There are very few items that I hit pan on but this is one of them. It's a holy grail product for sure. I mostly use the right side. It works for eyes and cheeks. The white square makes an amazing inner corner highlight. The quality rivals high end makeup. Please don't ever stop...
KLEANCOLOR Color Playlist - Color Playlist

1 review

This palette is my favorite palette to use for when I have a special event to go to. Since it has many bright color and dark color it is easy to experiment with different tones. Coming from an Indian background, the colours are perfect for my skin tone and the colours have a...
Mary Kay cream eye colour Apricot twist

1 review

J'ai essayé durant les dernières semaines le fard à paupière en crème de Mary Kay Abricot savoureux. Je peux dire que je l'adore avec sa belle couleur lustrée. Il fait ressortir mes yeux bleus avec une belle luminosité. Sa longue tenue est merveilleuse, je l'applique le...
Lancôme color design eyeshadow palette in taupe craze

1 review

I have two of these palettes. My favorite one is the one called "Taupe Craze" that has very neutral colors. I really liked the quality of these shadows and the practical packaging. The shadows are very pigmented and buttery. One palette has 5 shades and you can create a lot of...
Wet 'n Wild Eye Shadow Trio Spoiled Brat

1 review

Here's another surprise! I came across this little eyeshadow trio at CVS and couldn't believe it! Absolutely gorgeous colors! And glitter too! #336/Spoiled Brat. Wears very well and goes on easily. I just love it. Please try it!
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eye Chrome

1 review

These cream eyeshadows are so pigmented, easy to use, and will not smudge. Ever. I've used them as eyeliner, in my inner corner, bottom lashline, and on my lid and they stay beautiful and bright all day.