Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
481-500 of 1574

NYX Dream Catcher Palette Gold Horizons

2 reviews

My new favorite palette at the moment. I love trying different eye palettes and this one is superb! I have tried NYX eye shadows in the past but this one is the best for me. It goes on beautifully. Is super pigmented and stays on all day ( bonus) . I love the secret mirror...
Miss A baked eyeshadows

2 reviews

This product is to me average, I like it and use it but only buy it if it's on sale or when it's gifted. I am sorry to say I don't find it to be anything that special just an ordinary run of the mill eyeshado.
NYX Ultra Pearl Mania

1 review

Right from the start, I loved the packaging! It's unique for an eyeshadow product, and it really attracted my attention. I love the font too! But now, the makeup: I use this as an eyeshadow even though it's technically a pigment. It has an amazingly smooth feel when applied and...
Inspr eyeshadow carnival

1 review

Love this palate! Great colour, shimmery purple-brown town, stays put much better than most shimmery powder. My go to shadow on time crunch mornings. Matches most everything
Maybelline The City Mini Palette x Shayla

3 reviews

This product made me break out. The skin on my eyelids first became very red and then was dry and peeling. It has taken a very long time to both heal and also identify the source of the allergy. I like the colors though which is why I gave this not all 1 stars.
Jelly Pong Pong Supercharged super intense eyeshadow

1 review

I think the eyeshadow is so good. I got it in my iPsy bag and I love both the colours. This eyeshadow is one of my favourite subscription bag items. The website charges $22 for the pallet
Dior 5-Colour Eye Shadow Quad

33 reviews

I love it!! its amazing .Im so in love with this product and i will strongly recommend to family and my friend.I would love to try it again and again.
Smashbox Photo Matte Eyes Travel Palette

4 reviews

I have been using this product for almost two years and it never fails to impress. It has the nicest transition shades and gives beautiful and blend able matte shades. I also use the darkest brown as to fill in my eyebrows and it looks so natural. You can do so much with this...
Covergirl eyeshadow sable

1 review

Cover girl eyeshadows are a longtime favorite of mine. The one I use the most is in the color of sable. Just gives the right shimmer for day or night. One of the classic shadows. Less costly and just as effective as those expensive brands. Doesn't irritate my senative eyes.
Mary Kay At Play Shadow And Liner

15 reviews

I love this duo stick. It is perfect for ladies on the go started in college or a busy mommy. The shadow feels so good on the lids, and if you want it to last super long you can set it with a shadow that matches the color. The linef I actually do like a lot. It has shimmer in it...
Tarte chocolate bar eyeshadow palette

1 review

This is a wonderful palette for my skin colouration, it's now the one I use every day. I can go from a very natural daytime look to a night time look easily and depending on the boldness of the colours I choose and how much I build the product. Very happy with it.
Carli Bybel Eyeshadow palette

5 reviews

I love all of the colours in the pallette. The matte colours are very pigmented and apply to your skin really well, however I can't say the same about the shimmer shades. I find these do not apply properly on my lids. I do think this item is good for the price that I paid since...
Maybelline New York Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads, Lavender Smokes

2 reviews

This eyeshadow palette is not bad at all as the colours are very mild and it goes on very smoothly. For that intense look, I damp my brush and it comes out really well!
NYX Nude On Nude Palette

4 reviews

I like very much this palette. It’s afordable, perfect for people who’s starting makeup. It has a nice range of shades to make a nice everyday look and transitions into night looks. The glosses I don’t care much for them but the shadows are nice, some are chalky and not...
Revlon colour stay eye shadow

1 review

Very modern colour, goes on immaculately, bought it for a wedding, ending up being an every day use! Mixes well, awesome colour choices. Best eye shadow I've owned!! Totally worth the $$
nyx vivid brights creme colour

1 review

To be honest this product was not what I was expecting. After watching a bunch of youtubers rave about this I decided to buy it. However, it was so hard to use. It’s as if the product was stale upon buying it and had a hard time putting it on. The only good thing is that...
SEPHORA COLLECTION Colorful Eyeshadow - Lazy Afternoon

1 review

this really had no pigment and to get any you have to apply a lot, i have very fair skin though so it may have just matched it to much, i found it came off easy as well, i dont think ill buy the colour lazy afternoon again
Pixi eyeshadow

4 reviews

Ces ombres à paupière offre un beau rapport qualité prix.. Les couleurs sont splendides et la tenue est très bonne. Ils ont beaucoup de couleur iridescentes. Je les utilise chaque jour.
Lorac Pro Palette

24 reviews

The Lorac Pro Pallette is the best one I've ever used. I swear I have never used anything like this in terms of eye shadow, it seems to "melt" it so softly that it is, passionate and obvious that passionate about colors also is not mine pink face Super pigmented, just touch...
Natasha Denona Star Palette

3 reviews

Natasha Denona eyeshadow palettes are worth the money. They seem a bit pricey initially but they blend like a dream. You truly get what you pay for with this palette - so many looks can be created. I apply these with my finger then blend out the crease with a simple blending...