Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
521-540 of 1574

E.l.f. cosmetics necessary nude palette

1 review

I got this palette free with am e.l.f. order and it was an awesome addition to my eye shadow collection. Great mix of shimmers and mattes, that consist of neutral. Great for natural looks or an even looks!
Mica Beauty Shimmer Powder

3 reviews

I love how I can not only use this on my eyes but also on my cheeks or anywhere I want a little highlight 😉 I have the beige one and it gives just three right amount of shimmer.
Maybelline New York The City Mini Palette, Chill Brunch Neutrals

2 reviews

I was first attracted to this pallet because of the purple colors but I was sadly disappointed. The paper of the two purples is more white and the darker one comes out a smokey blacky-purple definitely not what I was looking for but the glitter pigments are beautiful
Covergirl eye enhancers Pure Romance

1 review

This is a great four colour eye shadow palette. The colors look great and blend really well. They seem to last quite well and just look great. One of my favourites !!
Urban decay moon dust eyeshadow palette

4 reviews

This eyeshadow palette Is just stunning ! The colors are amazing ! It’s give you nice shine and the size of the palette Is good ! It’s worth buying it ! I would highly recommend it to everyone if you like shimmery eyeshadow !
Laura Mercier Eye Art Artist's Palette

1 review

The palette case is a rich brown with black embossing on it and is very tactile as it is cushioned. The magnetic clasp is pretty strong, so won’t fall open unexpectedly. Inside there is a mirror that fills the lid and 12 shadows that look beautiful in their neutral and purple...
bhcosmetics - Pride+Prejudice+Zombies Palette

1 review

I love this palette, I use it every day. It has mostly neutral colours but it has two purples (dark and light) and I just love the little pop of colour that you could add if this was the only palette you owned.
e.l.f Cosmetics Ultra Pigment Cushion Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

I purchased this eyeshadow out of curiosity, because it looked interesting, and I had no idea I would love it as much as I do! It has the consistency of putty, so you need a firm brush to apply, but holy moley, the PIGMENT! It makes my eyelids looks so shiny and dewy, so far...
Emani Vegan Cosmetics Emani Minerals Crushed Mineral Color Dust Ms Know It All

1 review

This colour is really vibrant. I bought it specifically to go with an outfit I own and it looks great! I love how easy it was to use. It's small. Careful not to spill it when opening. It lasts a long time too!
INT cosmetics - goddess gold eyeshadow

2 reviews

Product has a great colour too it. However, once I used up the first layer I have a hard time of getting much shadow onto the brush. I loved the colour so that's a little disappointing.
Half baked urban decay

2 reviews

I absolutely love the colors in this pallet. I love nude colors but I also love glitter so this is the perfect pallet for me. It goes on well and blends so good.
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Leather Effect eyeshadow in 80-Creamy Beige

2 reviews

I wasn't a big fan of the regular color tattoos but I found that this "leather' one has a different formula and I prefer it. It's a little thicker and opaque, so it does actually last all day, that I can't get the others to do. So it's a great cream shadow, opaque, dries down...
Lorac Unzipped Gold

2 reviews

I bought this pallet about 3 years ago and it’s still my number one go to pallet! You have 4 matte shades and 6 shimmer shades. A little goes a long way, I can dip my brush on a color and it will color my whole lid! Also another great thing about this pallet is the colors are...
Physicians formula shimmer strips dramatic

1 review

I've had the same eyeshadow set for the last 4 years that's how well this product works! It gives a good long lasting pigment in a variety of shades to play with. One of my favourite pieces of my makeup collection by far.
BH Cosmetics special occasion palette

1 review

so i have a few BH cosmetic pallets and let me just say they are bomb! they are very afordable and pigmented they blend easily and you can always build up the color
The Balm Overshadow

1 review

A thinly-milled, mineral, metallic eye shadow (try saying that five times fast) is pretty much what dreams are made of. This long last formula makes your eyes look bright and awake, especially if you pop it in the inner corner. What is even better is that this product can be...
L'Oréal Colour Riche

1 review

There are four colors in this eyeshadow. They all work well together also you don't have to wear all four you can wear a solid color. I like the Browns.
City Color Cosmetics Shimmer Shadow in Beach Cottage

2 reviews

This shadow is so vibrant, shimmery, and gorgeous. It really brings out the green in my hazel eyes. A very bold look, and a little goes a long way. Feels velvety smooth on my skin, and so sparkly. Gorgeous for an evening look, or for a fun, colourful daytime look.
Love & beauty Eye shadow duo - Champagne

2 reviews

Most amazing colors in the world ! Looks great on my eyes and skin! Everyone should be wearing this! I recommend this to all my friends and family! Beautiful colors. Never found anything better than this!
Two Faced Chocolate Bar Palette

15 reviews

I finally got over a year ago and I still love it. The shimmers are so rich and it smells delicious. I only wish some of the darker shimmers were either lighter or matte. It is hard to find a good use for them with my skin tone. Also, I'm still figuring it out but I...