Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
641-660 of 1574

Batter Up Long Wearing Eyeshadow Stick by The Balm Cosmetics

1 review

These cream shadow sticks are very long lasting, work great as a base for powder shadow, look great worn on their own and come in a range (8) of beautiful very wearable shades. They cost a reasonable $17 each. I definitely recommend and I will be purchasing more!
Maybelline Expert Wear Golden Halo

2 reviews

This eyeshadow is so pigmented that you only need one swipe on your applicator, or eyeshadow brush to apply to your eyelid. The color is perfect for a summer glow. All you need is a bit of eyeliner on the upper eyelid for an easy daytime look. For a more dramatic evening eye, I...
Clinique Lid Pop in Petal Pop

1 review

I do love Clinique products. They have reliable formulas and I have never had any problems with Clinique on my skin. I bought the Clinique Lid Pop in Petal Pop which is shimmering pink colour in the container. It is a buttery consistency but the colour pay off wasn't as good as...
Too Faced Love Palette Eye Shadow

3 reviews

I purchased this palette at Marshall's for a much smaller price than Sephora or Too Faced's webpage, which is why I put the stars in the middle of the road. What I paid is much better than its regular price. Regardless, I'm so happy I purchased this palette. I have hazel eyes...
MAC Paint Pot Groundwork

2 reviews

I cannot imagine life without this product! I use it every day before applyinng my eye shadow, it has never let me down! Works wonderfully to prevent creasing.
Too Faced Natural Matte Eye Palette

7 reviews

I love cruelty free Too Faced Cosmetics and the Too Faced Natural Matte Neutral Matte Eye Shadow Palette did not disappoint. I received the palette in the Too Faced Spring Mystery Set. I was not a fan of mattes (preferred shimmers) until I discovered Too Faced. In my photos I...
maybelline expert eye shadow - taupe

1 review

I have had this eyeshadow forever. It is great for blending with others, but I don't use it alone. It is shiny and good for a night out. I prefer nudes during the day.
M.A.C trend forecast spring 17/ eye

1 review

The formula, wear time, texture, and pigmentation are spot on. The only issue I had, which is a big one, is the shades offered. The "on trend" shades were a bit boring and lackluster, and really didn't go well together if you wanted to use the palatte for an eye look.
Almay intense i-color shimmer-i for Greens

1 review

I purchased this on a whim because I was really drawn to the deep emerald crease colour that I find goes well with my dark brown hair. I was so pleasantly surprised by the quality and pigmentation of these shadows! The green especially as I've hardly made a dent in because it is...
Jane Iredale Eye Steppes Eye Shadow Go Warm

1 review

Just loving this eye shadow compact. Packaging is cool and convenient. Round and fits in palm of hand. 3 swivel out layers of shadows with 5 shadows in all. The first level has a lightest base color and the 2 other levels have 2 colors each of medium and darker shades...
elf flawless eyeshadow happy hour

1 review

This elf eyeshadow quad in happy hour is amazing. They are so reasonably priced and last through a lot of applications! Each strip of eyeshadow has a word imprinted into it give you a suggestion of where to apply it on your eye, for example `lid`. The colours are all so...
NYX Prismatic Shadow in Bedroom Eyes

1 review

Very light, creamy and shimmery. Love the colour of this shadow. Can be applied for a light, delicately shimmery look, or apply a few layers to get a more dramatic look. Feels so silky and lovely on my skin. Very shimmery/shiny so would look fab for a glam night out.
e.l.f. Aqua Beauty Molten Liquid Eyeshadow

4 reviews

I didn't have high hopes for this product as I have extremely oily eyelids. Eyeshadow primers never work for me, and powder shadows last a few hours before creasing. Because of this, I never purchased a liquid shadow before and expected it to just slide into my crease like...
Elf Eyes Lips Face Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

A sleek palette that includes a wide range of (kind of) pigmented colours. I believe that there are other palettes in this line, so I don't know the specific name of this one. However, these colours are great for blending into other looks (I blend them into looks with my Naked...
Lise Watier Quatuor Eyeshadow Quartet in Les Basiques

1 review

First of all the packaging of this is gorgeous! The shadows are also very nice, the darker shades are a bit more pigmented and soft compared to the lighter shades which are a bit more powdery. However, when used together the shadows work out fantastically and stay on for the...
NYX Roll on shimmer

2 reviews

I love this product on days where I don't want to fuss with eyeshadow because it is so quick and easy to apply. all I do is apply a cream eyeshadow or a liquid eye primer as a base so the shimmer has something to stick to and apply the shimmer to my lids. The ball applicator...
Colourpop where the light is

1 review

I got this on Black Friday because it was on sale. I am still getting use to use this type of formula. I like the lighter colour for a highlighter underneath the brow. It's best to use your finger to apply. The other colours are great for your lid and they blend well. Goes on...
Borghese Eclissare Color Shadow And Light Luminous Eye Palette

1 review

I love this palette even tho the colors that are shown in the back of the box aren't accurate. I don't know if it's my skin tone or I'm not using the right eyeshadow primer but they look way different once I apply them. But the pigments are really nice! I still like the colors...
Naked Cosmetics Heavy Metal #04

1 review

I got this eyeshadow in my Ipsy bag. I was turned off right away because it is a loose powder. I do like the shade. It is a copper that does look metallic. It a applied beautiful but you do need a cream base to make it stick well. I would be willing to try more shade from this...
Urban Decay Eyeshadow in Baked

2 reviews

One of my favorite eye shadows. It come has part of a special value kit I had gotten from Sephora I believe. This product was my favorite out of kit by a long shot- and all the items in the kit were really good too- so that's saying a lot. IT's so easy to work with and stays...