Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
681-700 of 1574

Quo Beauty in Bloom Palette

1 review

Six separate spaces that include three corresponding colours that are created to group the colours into similar groups (hopefully this makes sense), so a total of 18 colours. The colour trios are nice and the colours work great with each other, and the whole palette works...
Mary Kay Rock the Runway Palette

1 review

Compared to last season's summer eyeshadow palette, the price of this one makes much more sense. $26 for shades this pigmented and easy to use is definitely something I can get onboard with! Each shade was deliciously pigmented and even the blue can be worn day to day when...
Elf Glitter Eye Palette

2 reviews

I've had a lot of fun playing with the different eye makeup colours in this set. I find them blendable and I like the little instruction sheet that comes with the makeup set for extra guidance. Also, I find this eye set affordable!
Urban Decay Skull Shadow Box

1 review

This was the very first Urban Decay product I bought, when I was just eighteen and didn't have a Sephora near me. I had my parents drive me two hours out of town to get to the nearest one, where I found this palette and began my love affair with the brand. Although this...
revelon colorstay 16 hour Eye Shadow

4 reviews

Love this product. Stays in place. No clumping, no ridges. Good price point:) variety of colours to choose from. Like the application diagram that shows you how to apply
Sonia Kashuk Neutral Neutral Palette 2

1 review

I decided to get this palette because I know I only like neutrals vs fancy colors. I think for its price point it's pretty good. Overall, it's pigmented but not so much for some shades. I still like it because it is my first eyeshadow palette and I'm still experimenting colors...
quo pallet

1 review

its not a bad pallet but i just dont use it. i thought id use it more than i do. i own it in the smokey eye pallet but it has a lot of fallout. the only thing i love is the cream silver shadown cuz i can use that as a liner if i want
Maybelline Expert Wear Eye Shadow Quad in Charcoal Smokes

1 review

This review is specifically for the Charcoal Smokes quad (there are several other shade combinations available). I tend to prefer medium-dark shades that are cool-toned, and this combination of grey, taupe, cool brown, and black shades works really well on my skin tone. I've...
Urban Decay Eye Shadow | Virgin

2 reviews

My favourite base that I apply over my Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion. It's just the right amount of sparkle! It goes on wonderfully and lasts all day. Perfect for casual wear and going out.
Hard Candy Eye Shadow Primer

14 reviews

I use mostly all hardcandy products for my face because they have such a variety of colors and shades. If you use bright colored eyeshadow I would definately recommend this stuff. Just a little dab applied to both eyes and smeared, will make your eyeshadow last all day and into...
Hikari Cream Pigment

5 reviews

I can't rave about this eyeshadow enough! The colour is freaking gorgeous and definitely makes your eyes pop! I like to use it wet for a more glamorous effect!
Mary Kay Mineral Eyeshadow - Azure

3 reviews

For just $9 (Canadian), you can have a cute, fun, long-staying eye colour. And: It's a Mineral Powder Eye Shadow!! How perfect is that? Light-weight, great coverage, and a super colour!
Almay Intense I-colour 402 smoky-i for blues

1 review

This trio was not well planned. The colours can't create a decent eye look. The mini palette comes with a medium blue shade, a coppery brown and a silvery white, all of them shimmers. If the brown has been a matte shade, then it could be used as a good crease shade, but its...
Urban Decay Ammo Palette

13 reviews

I miss the colour SHATTERED. I have only seen it as part of this palette and it is my perfect shade. Alas this palette is discontinued and I have run out of SHATTERED. It is a sad, sad thing.However, this is my favourite combination of colours which I have used for years and am...
BH Cosmetics 88 Matte Shades Palette

2 reviews

I love BH! Such a great and affordable brand. The shadows aren't overly pigmented but for the price I can't complain. I used this palette almost everyday
Pacifica natural mineral eye shadow trio

2 reviews

I stumbled across this little hidden gem when a friend had it in her ipsy rejection pile that I always root through. I was intrigued by the tones (skinny dip, crush, and lovely) and the vegan ingredients. Not to mention a portion of sales goes towards a clean water project. The...
NYX Cosmetics ipsy eye shadow trio

6 reviews

I haven't touched the black even once but I really like the light nude colour and the gold for every once in a while.I like the sparkle to it and use it often very laid back makeup days.
NYC HD color trio eye shadow - 792 Streets Paved in Gold

1 review

It's a cheaper eyeshadow pallet, but their pretty nice colours, they take a little work to blend and aren't as pigmented and some other NYC products, but their semi buildable, I usually use them for transition colours when I'm going with nudes.. Their shimmery but not super...
M Princess Pressed Chestnut Eye Shadow

1 review

This eye shadow is so easy to apply -- either with a brush or with your finger. A creamy shadow that feels light on the skin, and leaves my skin feeling silky soft. The shimmery brown colour is gorgeous and looks fab with most looks.
Mac eye shadow satin taupe

3 reviews

This is my favorite eye shadow. I use it as a base and as a highlighter. The color lasts all day without fading and makes my eyes pop. It lasts forever. I do use it every day and have purchased a second one, but it will last you a while.