Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
721-740 of 1574

Annabelle Smokey Nudes Palette

3 reviews

Je trouve que la qualité de cette palette est vraiment super! La pigmentation des fards est vraiment très bonne, ils sont tous très pigmentés. Certains sont un peu poudreux, mais pas trop. Je trouve aussi que la plupart des couleurs se marient vraiment très bien ensemble...
Eye Studio by Maybelline

6 reviews

I love this eye shadow! It’s very smooth and when I set the Bruh the entire eyeshadow doesn’t get ruined! It’s very well pressed and is very vibrant and beautiful!!
Ofra Bliss eyeshadow/highlighter

2 reviews

I got this eyeshadow/highlighter in an Ipsy bag,and have been using it as the base colour for my daily shadow for my everyday look for years! Then I just add some brown shadow to my creases for depth.
Smashbox Double Exposure Eyeshadow Palette

9 reviews

The packaging is nice with a sturdy feeling palette with a magnetic clasp and a good size mirror in the lid. The palette consists of 14 eyeshadows (7 shimmer, 4 satin and 3 matte) and a double ended brush. The brush has one end which is domed and the other angled. The palette is...
Almay intense  i-color evening smoky

2 reviews

I haven't used too many Almay make up products, but this I Color in Evening Smokey is pretty cool. I have greenish blue eyes, and the smokey purple, charcoal, and silver go well with them and enhance them for a sexy or night out look You just follow 3 steps. The package tells...
revolution palette

3 reviews

Great purchase. All pallets from them are great value for money. Not the best quality but you get what you pay for. Interesting colours with some beautiful shimmers.
L'Oreal Infallible Smokissime Eyeliner

1 review

I got this at a private sale for pretty cheap as it is about $12 and I got it for $4. I returned and bought 3. I love how easy it is to apply. It goes on a bit thick unless you wipe off excess at the side. I just blend. I really like it and wish all my eyeshadows came with a...
Revlon Eye Shadow 4pk

3 reviews

This is a very affordable eyeshadow product in a very pretty array of colours. My pet peeve with these quads is that the brushes do not work well and I’m not sure why they continue to provide them! Additionally, I find that these are best used with an eyeshadow primer as they...
Elf Beauty Journal - Smoky Look

3 reviews

This would be awesome for someone who doesn't have a tonne of makeup, but if you do already have lots you most likely have all of these things in your collection. The eyeshadow is pigmented and a nice mix of mattes and glitters. The eye primer is the bomb. The brush is useful...
urban decay eye shadow in lounge

2 reviews

This eye shadow is so gorgeous! I love how it transitions from green to red, depending on the light. Makes for a gorgeous daytime or nighttime look. So lightly, smoothly, and goes on so easily. Makes my lids feel soft and velvety. One of my favourite colours ever for shadow.
annabelle pressed eyeshadow

1 review

This is my favorite eyeshadow. Its always a great price and there are so many unique shades. I use this almost daily. I apply it first thing in the morning and it lasts all day. I never need to retouch. Highly reccomend
TheBalm Meet Matt(e) Nude Eyeshadow Palette

4 reviews

So I bought this product in may and when it was July I swear to you some of the eye shadows turned green. I had to spray setting spray to use them since they are all dry I will not suggest u to buy this
M.A.C studio eye gloss

1 review

I know it says it's tacky, but it's tacky to the point of being so sticky your eyelids actually stick when you blink! It does not dry down at all, so it feels strange and wet all day long. Also, does not blend nicely at all.
MAC eye shadow in Retrospeck

3 reviews

Really liked this eye shadow it sat the lid nicely, no clumping in the eye folds which I hate. It lasted all day and gave a nice sheen to my lid with a professional looking finish
LA Girl Beauty Brick Neon

1 review

This is my favorite palette that I own. The colours very with green, blue, purple, and pink. They are all neon colours so they look amazing and really make your eyes pop.
MAC Eye Shadow in Expensive Pink

4 reviews

This product is very shimmery and looks amazing in the container or if you do a swatch on your hand. On the eye it completely changes. You have to apple many strokes before it turns shimmery. Otherwise it is a very good quality because it is soft and doesn't fly everywhere.
Marcelle Eye Shadow Quad (Smoke Signals)

4 reviews

I am really impressed by how smoothly this eyeshadow applies, and how long this eyeshadow stays put. I am up during the week at five thirty and usually have my makeup applied by six thirty. This Marcelle eyeshadow will still look fabulous twelve hours later, without me having to...
NYC Eyeshadow Palette

10 reviews

I am loving using this eyeshadow palette during this hot, humid summer that we have been having over the past two weeks. In my opinion, this is the perfect summer palette as all the colors compliment one another. If you have a bit of a tan, these eyeshadows will provide you with...
Lord & Taylor the working girl makeup set

1 review

This product was about $15 in Hudson Bay. This is great for a beginner or mini makeup touch up palate. Here's why.... These eye shadows on my hand are not very stain very nicely as I thought. Smooth but not very pigmented. I like the Browns in this palate some shimmery and the...
Nyx "Bedroom Eyes" Prismatic Sahadows

4 reviews

This shadow is a lovely colour that compliments many eye colours well. I gift it to my mom often and she loves it too! I love NYX products, which can sometimes be hit-or-miss, but this is a hit.