Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
741-760 of 1574

Marcella Eye Shadow Quad Nouveau Nude

3 reviews

the drug store had a sale on Marcella products so I splurged a little. on some make-up. I really like it. it stays smooth looking through out the day. and is a nice feeling on my skin.
Mary Kay At Play Eye Crayon

15 reviews

This product is perfect to put in your purse because it can help you in desperate times of need! The liner is thin and permits you to create the perfect line.
Pixi by Petra Mini Shade Quartette, shades of Daylight

1 review

I had such high hopes for the little travel quad, these are my first and only Pixi shadows I've tried out. These 4 shades are what I typically gravitate to, a light highlight, champagne, copper and darker brown. These shades looks beautiful as they have a slight shimmer to them...
NARS And God Created the Woman Set (LE)

1 review

Probably my favorite neutral eyeshadow palette and I have 'em all. I love the level of pigment (buildable, excellent when I get really into it and want to "construct" my eye shape). The long-wear, with any primer is outstanding, and the shades themselves are heaven. I like a mix...
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eye Shadow - Barely Branded

11 reviews

Je les adore !!! Peu importe la couleur il sont tout simplement génial. La tenue, la couleur, la pigmentation tout est wow. Le seul petit hic que je peux voir est l'application. On est pas trop précis avec les doigts. Je crois qu'il faut que je développe une technique pour...
Revlon perfect finish eye shadow

1 review

I love this eye shadow, if you use makeup brushes it goes on so smoothly. The color combo nations are intense. Myself, I like the Browns and bronzes and dark colours
Dr. Hauschka Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

I absolutely love this product because just a little bit goes a long way! It works wonderful with my skin, I have dry skin and it feels flawless on my skin and even looks better. The colors are a little bit powdery. They are pretty but instead of looking set they always look...
Tarte amazonian after dark eyeshadows and face palette

4 reviews

I absolutely love this palette, I bought it on a whim. And it has surpassed my expectations, it's very pigmented and the contour/blush are so natural looking when applied my only complaint would be the highlight. It doesn't come off well onto a brush. I have to use my finger to...
bh comestics galaxy chic

4 reviews

This is my first time trying anything from BHcosmetic. I’m very happy with my choice. There is 18 well pigmented , shimmery and baked colors. Applying is very easy, blending with other colors very nicely. There are never ending combinations,for every day or night out...
theBalm Nude 'tude eyeshadow palette

2 reviews

I love it because they are long-wearing shadows, I love every colour of the palette, they are natural colours and all shadows can be used wet or dry, and I love the packaging too
Elf Shimmer Palette

1 review

Elf's Shimmer Palette is so pretty. The case it comes in is very well constructed its a solid case which is important in the event you drop your purse or God forbid you drop the palette. The shimmers are soft colors perfect for any and all occasions. The smell is similar to...
Manna Kadar Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Fantasy

2 reviews

I love this eyeshadow. This is my go to when I want a natural shimmery look. Makes my eyes pop. Easy to apply, no clumps. Great for a night out or an everyday look.
nyc lovatics by demi

5 reviews

The quality of this palette is amazing, especially for the price it is offered at. Every time I go into a Walmart, there are only about two palettes left on display. Some of the shimmers could be a bit more pigmented and there is quite a bit of kickback but the shadows feel...
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eye Shadow - Bad To The Bronze

11 reviews

I used to be obsessed with this stuff. It was easy to apply and it lasted forever. It didn't budge, it didn't crease and it was a one step process. It made doing makeup easy. Love it! I don't know if maybelline still makes them but they were a drugstore Gem!
Echo Acc 120 Colors Eyeshadows

1 review

I love having a variety of eye shadows – in the same token, I also get really bored of the same colours all the time with larger sized eye shadows. These eyeshadows come in a plastic box, and TWO layers of eyeshadows (60 colours per palette). There is a colour for every...
L.A. Colors 5 Color Matte Eyeshadow Blue Denim

1 review

The packaging and presentation is great! The colours are really appealing. unfortunately the shadow is chalky, no pigment and ended up on the rest of my face. Wouldn't stick to the skin.
Hard Candy Look Neutral Eyes

1 review

In my opioin this is more of a beginner kit because most of the colors are fairly dull and it's hard to get a long lasting look, on the plus side theres lots of colors and glitters and a bigginer to the make up world could use this pallet fairly easily and get some good results!
Stila Cosmetics Eyes Are The Window Shadow Palette in Mind

2 reviews

I absolutely love this palette. The packaging is so beautiful and chic and worth the money . I got this palette at Sephora and it was around the same price point and all the other palettes on the market. The formulas of this palette are great and very pigmented. I like the...
Maybelline Eye Studio Color Tattoo Eye Shadow - Leathers Chocolate Suede

1 review

I love this eyeshadow. So flattering! Chocolate Suede is a deep shade of cocoa brown with a hint of warm gold. Neutral with a little something extra. I think these Color Tattoos are great. So easy to use they're absolutely idiot-proof. Just use your fingers to dab it on and...
Mac Amber x9

5 reviews

The palette is gorgeous and the shades are beautiful I love the palette and they blend together with ease I love it and like using it anytime definitely recommend