Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
821-840 of 1574

Covergirl Eye Enhancers 710 champagne

1 review

This may be the only drugstore eye shadow that I regularly use. This champagne colour is my go to highlighter. It has great pigment and a nice sparkle to it. I use it in the inside corner of my eyes and under my eyebrows to give me the "pop". It makes my eye colour appear nice...
Pixi by Petra- Mesmerizing mineral duo in LAVENDER BLOOM

4 reviews

I love this little shadow, such warm colours. Pigment is nice and wears well. Blends perfectly as well. Received mine in an Ipsy package. Totally recommend pixi shadows
smashbox full exposure duo

2 reviews

Great natural color with an added shimmer. Looks amazing on. Great for everyday or a night on the town. Not clumpy goes on smooth. I would recommend this product.
nicka k eye light crayon

2 reviews

I have to say I LOVE the Nicka K New York-Eye Light Crayon the colour is Bronze I LOVE the colour, it is very rich and pigmented, a little goes a long way. The colour is perfect for my skin tone! I love the retractable pen applicator it makes it super easy to apply, I love it...
enchanted eyes dual ended eye wand

2 reviews

#Enchanted (Eyes Dual Ended Eye Wand) I just love this product it is like getting two pencils in one. Comes in a variety of shades. Who ever thought of this idea is pure genius. Highly recommend adding this to your cosmetic collection.
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Sassy Chamallow

1 review

I love this colour. It's super unique, it's blue but there's almost pink reflects through it. I hit pan and I haven't been able to find it again though :(
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Metallic Lilac

1 review

I love this shade, it's super stunning. This is the hardest one out of the line to work with, but the end result is amazing
pacifica mystical Supernatural eyeshadow palette

1 review

The colors are truly pigmented.By swatching the eyeshadows i noticed how creamy and soft the formula is but as i started picking them with my brush i noticed that they are a little bit powdery and they have some fallout.The colors are so easy to blend.if you don’t mind fallout...
Marc Jacobs Twinkle Pop

3 reviews

I bought my first Twinkle Pop in black and found it to be a little too light for black (come on).... but i made it work and blend it with my smokey eyes. my next shade was the brown and and after that, I fell in love. it's so creamy and blends so well. it doesn't smudge and...
NYX Prismatic Shadow in Blue Jean

1 review

The Multi-Dimensional Shimmer of this little NYX Prismatic Shadow Pot in Blue Jean is pretty amazing and very long wearing. I picked it up at my local London Drugs for about $6.00 and I have to say it's fabulous quality and loads of pigment for a teenie little price. In love!
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Gilded Envy

1 review

This is such a gorgeous olive colour!!! I love how it looks on the eye
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Goldmine

1 review

This is one of my favourite gold eyeshadows, it's so gorgeous when it sparkles in the light. Plus it's so affordable and glides on the eye nice when you use your finger
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Smoldering Plum

1 review

The formula on these shadows in one of the best I have ever tried, but the colour to me is so dark that it doesn't even look like purple, it just looks black
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Purple Priority

1 review

I love this colour becuase it actually looks purple on the eye, other purples just look black but this one is a nice bright purple
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Burst into Bloom

1 review

This is such a nice purple, it's not too bright so it's easy to wear as an everyday shade and it blends so well
Tarte Tartlette Matte Eyeshadow Palette

6 reviews

So, in my opinion this pallete is perfect for begginners. It gives you a good variety of colours that are pretty easy to work with. However, for more skilled individuals who already have many products in their arsenal its not something that will be reached for often.
Merle Norman Cosmetics Eye Shadow

2 reviews

have oily skin with large pores, redness, and old acne scars...This is my favorite powder foundation...It controls oil, covers my red, does not oxidize, and does not accentuate my pores or scars...With primer, this will stay on for 7-8 hours."
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Eternal Sunshine

1 review

I love this colour because it can look gold or peach or orange depending on the light and it's absolutely stunning on the lid
e.l.f. Cosmetics Baked Eye Shadow

10 reviews

I received this product as a gift from the elf website. I really liked the colours but this is such a horrible product. It's pretty much rock. I couldn't get any pigment off of it even after I tried scraping it and even wetting it a little and nothing. Do not buy this product.
Coastal Scents styleEYES Palette Trio

1 review

I recieved a sample from the glamour eyes palette in my December Birchbox and instantly fell in love with the eyeshadows. With one swipe the colour payoff was incredible and absolutely stunning. I gave them a test run and indeed decided I needed to spend all my birchbox points...