Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
861-880 of 1574

Peony cosmetics shadow trio

1 review

I've tried quite a few metallic eyeshadows lately, particularly in bronzes and golds so when Ipsy sent me this I was on the verge of an eyeroll! I rescind, this blows all the other bronzes out of the water! The pigment on the Peony eyeshadows is incredible. It really goes on...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Long Lasting Lustrous Eye Shadow

3 reviews

I love this eyeshadow. The pigment is fabulous, it is long lasting. This just looks great on me. I love the texture of this cream shadow. The price is great and really makes this product worth it.
SEPHORA Collection Ombre Obsession Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

Sephora is truly a great product and I love the wide range of colors etc!! ITS affordable and very available! if you want to wake up,, you eyes !!! Try this great product! you will love it also!!
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadows

3 reviews

Wesring this constantly just to give my eyes a little « pop » of glitter and shine! Love this subtle color 🧡. Though I will probably put an eye primer before, next time, so that it stays put! I would love to try other colors! There are so many!
Maybelline The Smokes Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

The price is very cheap but I advise you to pay more and get a better quality product. The product is not pigmented and it barely puts any color on my eyes lids. I liked the colors of the eyes hadows but I was very disappointed with the overall effectiveness of the product.
essence 3D Duo Eye Shadow

20 reviews

I have this eyeshadow duo in the shade Irresistible Purr-ple. These shadows are very eye catching and affordable. They have good pigmentation and blend well. They have shimmer but have more of a chrome like finish. I normally gravitate towards neutral shades so I use these to...
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Silver Sky

1 review

I Love this silver, especially for holiday looks and in the inner corner of the eye. It's a bit of a darker silver than the other silver from the same line
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Glistening Garnet

1 review

This is an awesome shade because it can look purple or even reddish depending on the light and how it reflects! Plus it's super pigmented
e.l.f. Cosmetics studio eyeliner & shadow stick

1 review

Love this. I like to have the shadow and eyeliner all in one. I have the colour plum/purple. It great to have the perfect combination for your eyes without having to thing about it. Both ends are swivel sticks and are super easy to use. It applies very nicely and you don't need...
e.l.f. Studio Endless Eyes Pro Mini Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

If you love smoky shimmery eyes this is the perfect palette for you. I love how there are so many different colours to play with and the shadow goes on easily with one stroke. The colours are dark enough so you don't need to continue putting layers on to get the effect you need...
Medusas Makeup Eyeshadow in Tarzan

1 review

This is the perfect glam neutral. It's a neutral color with shimmer in it. It's not chalky it has the quality of a high end eye shadow.
Glamour Doll Eyes in Drive Me matte

1 review

This pigment is the most beautiful shade. It's the perfect neutral shade.
Coulor Pop Pigments

1 review

Coulor Pop pigments and shadows do just that, they make your eyes pop. They are very bright and noticeable. Definitely worth every penny and very cost efficient!
Ardency Inn  Rebel long play cream eyeshadow in Paint Them Black

1 review

This product is great. It smudges well for a smoky eye but work fast, once this formula sets it is locked in place. The colour is a matte intense black. Does not crease. The packaging keeps the product from drying out. Twist up and the shadow is then applied by brush.
NYX love in rio en fuego

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes
e.l.f. Cosmetics brightening eye color luxe

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes and great too work with its an amazing little palette
wet n wild coloricon walking on eggshells

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes
nyx deep purple eye shadow

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes
wet n wild eye shadows knock on wood

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes
klean color

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes its easy to work with and it makes my eyes pop out so much