Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
901-920 of 1574

Too Faced Natural Eye Neutral Eye Shadow Collection

25 reviews

I couldn't find the exact match to leave a review. This too faced natural eyes pallet is just so stunning. It has some gorgeous nude colours that you can create a natural eye with or you can mix things up to create a gorgeous smoky eye. Quality is amazing and blends in lovely...
Pur Mineral Shadow- Midnight Jade

1 review

I love this forrest green colour. It works great for a smokey eye. It is decently pigmented but I still like to use a primer with it. There is a bit of fallout usually. I always keep a wet wipe close by.
Jesse's Girl Backstage Collection Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

I really liked the colors on this pallet! Will buy again for sure. lasted all day too
Too Faced Cat Eyes Palette

7 reviews

I just purchased this at Marshalls last week for so cheap (couldn't even believe it nor did I know they sold Too Faced products) I had to, of course, try it out the second I got home. The colors are beautiful- they blend very nicely and are very pigmented. You can blend the...
california collection bh cosmetics

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes , the colors are really nice and amazing too work with if you like to do smokey eyes
bombshell white pencil

1 review

love this its waaaay easier to apply and its amazing
pop bright up your life

1 review

i love this eye shadow the colors are amazing and it stays on long !! great for smoky eyes
Pop Beauty Pure Pigment Eye Shadow

2 reviews

I was excited to try this even though I don't usually like loose pigments, as I loved the color. Well I was not super impressed with the pigment. I will admit that I didn't bother trying it again with a primer.
pur mineral shadow- gold dust

1 review

What attracted me to this shadow was the shimmery pigment. I thought it would work perfect in the crease for subtle looks. This shadow has a smooth texture and it is highly pigmented. A little bit of product goes a long way. The packaging is pretty boring.
e.l.f. Cosmetics pigment eyeshadow naturally nude

1 review

Awesome powder in a gorgeous shade. Good everyday colour. More of a gold then a nude tone though.
Pacifica Eye Shadow

14 reviews

I found that everytime I put my brush to this eyeshadow palette I ended up with all kinds of loose powder all over. It stayed on okay but expect some on your cheeks.
Joe Fresh Eyeshadow Quad Clean Classics

2 reviews

Not to sure about this one. Thought it would be a bit better then what it is. It was even on sale but still didn't like the purchase maybe other products are ok
Gucci Magnetic Color Shadow Quad

1 review

these shadows are ultra soft and feel buttery; however, because the shadows are so plush, it is easy to overblend and there is a fine line between a beautiful smoky eye and a muddled mess!
Makeup geek shimashima

3 reviews

Beautiful champagne shimmer eye shadow. It would look good on many skin tones. Soft & buttery. Great for a lid shade, inner corner highlight or browbone highlight
Wet 'N Wild Coloricon Eyeshadow

2 reviews

This product really amazed me. It is silky smooth and highly pigmented! Something you would expect in a much more expensive product. The price is so cheap and the quality is so amazing! I own several colors and love them all!
Color Pop Eyeshadows

7 reviews

Je suis en amour avec la marque color pop! La qualité des fards est impressionnantes, sans odeur, de belles couleur flash qui se travaille bien. Le prix est vraiment bas pour la qualité. Je suis toujours surprise à chaque nouvelle palette que j'achète.
La colors mesmerize pallet

2 reviews

I love this eye shadow pallet I bought it a long time ago and it has lasted me so long. The colours are so pretty and they aren't too bold but nice soft colours.
Gosh effect powder apple jam

2 reviews

This eyeshadow and multiuse powder is very pretty and shiny. It looks beautiful and stays throughout the day. Good for both evening and day looks. Too bad this brand got discontinued at shoppers.
Covergirl shadow pot #300

1 review

I don't like this eyeshadow at all. I got in a beauty box subscription and I haven't tried Covergirl eyeshadow in long time so I was looking forward to it. What's disappointed. I found it way too dark and the shadow would fall onto the face. It also fall apart easy in the pot...
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Bottomless Java

1 review

The formula is AMAZING I just don't like the colour, it looks like baby poop on my eyelids. Bleh.