Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
921-940 of 1574

L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Endless Sea

1 review

I love this shadow. It's super pigmented, and is one of my favourites out of the entire line. It's incredible! Plus little fallout too
Alamy eyeshadow

6 reviews

I don't want to bash but I like a pop or rich long lasting colour for my eyes, not something that needs to be reapplied multiple times a day then that means you are burning through more money than ever on products that not good for me
Urban Decay Pulp Fiction Eyeshadow Palette

3 reviews

I have a lot of eyeshadow palettes but this is one of my favorite ! I bought It from sephora ( you cant also find It online ) it is expensive compared to drugstore palette but its quality is excellent ! You can make different looks with it so i recommand It !!
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Infinite Sky

1 review

I love this shade when I wear blue because it's a nice blue and blends well, plus it's sparkly and pretty, so it's a nice pop of colour on the lid. And the best thing is there is no fallout when I use my finger
pur minerals secret crush pallete

3 reviews

This is one of my favourite eye shadow palettes - I got it from Shoppers Drug Mart and even though it is a little pricey compared to some palettes (I think it was $42), it was definitely worth it. The shades are all highly pigmented and they are also very smooth and easy to...
Lovely me:ex you and eyes

1 review

This eye shadow can be purchased at the face shop and goes on just as glittery as shown! It is definitely a must have!
Quo Barely There Eye Palette

3 reviews

I missed this collection but found one last eyeshadow palette on the SDM 'sale' shelf. I ended up with a lovely set of pastel colours, many of which I will use as liner's but at $10 (on sale) you certainly can't complain about getting 8 new colours to play with.
L'oreal satin metals wear infinite

1 review

I have this in the " Brawnze" colour and I really love it ! I don't need a lot to have a nice browns colour ( I;ve had it for years and I'm not even half way through the eyeshadow . I use white as a base to give it a little bit of a pop, it also gives my eye a natural look.
Clinique Chubby Stick Shadow Tint for Eyes

8 reviews

I did not really like this lip balm as I found it to make my lips look chapped. I do not think it blends very well after application! The pigment was good. The price is a little too much
Colorevolution Eye Shadow in Barely There

1 review

I am in love with Colorevolution's Eye Shadow in the colour Barely There. It's a loose shadow and very sparkly. Just add it to any look for an awesome pop of sparkle. It stays in place and glams up any look. I definitely recommend this eye shadow to anyone.
smashbox Art Love Colour Palettes

2 reviews

Very nice colours. They look great on my skin tone. I am sensitive to eye shadows and I often have inflammation on my eyelids from wearing it. I have had no issues with this product.
BellaPierre Shimmer Powders

6 reviews

I loooooove the shimmer powders and I have used this product for many years because it's easy to use, it stays on and looks great! I always get compliments whenever I wear them. There are 56 colors to choose from, you are sure to find the perfect shades for you or you can get...
L.A. Colors 12 Colour Eyeshadow Palette in BEP421 Traditional

1 review

I like this palette because it offers a bunch of natural colours - I can match it almost exactly to my skin tone, and make the accent colours as close or dramatic as I want to. The little brushes that come with it aren't very good, but they get the job done. Pretty good for just...
be a bombshell cosmetics : bora bora

2 reviews

Love this shade of blue. So vibrant, bold and shimmery. I usually use a narrow tip brush to apply this shadow on top of my eyeliner, to provide a pop of colour to my look. Looks fabulous!
Fyrinnae Pixie Epoxy

1 review

This is phenomenal for use with loose pigment eye shadows. If I didn't have it, and was just swatching loose pigments on skin or normal eye primer, I would've been very disappointed. But Pixie Epoxy really brings out the magic in all my loose pigments (both Fyrinnae and other...
Wet N Wild Color Icon Single Shadow in Nutty

6 reviews

This is such a beautiful everyday color and so inexpensive!! Barely has any fall out and it lasts a long time!! It's also so easy to blend!! If you're not that great at doing eyeshadow looks, you simply can't go wrong with this!
Urban Decay Eyeshadow

29 reviews

Love the colors of these eyeshadows. Very vibrant and long lasting. Goes great with the primer to make it last all day. Very pigmented as well. Blends easily and not much fallout.
N.Y.C. Individual Eyes Custom Compact in 938 Union Square

1 review

i love this eye shadow it comes with a primer and illuminator with the use of the primer before putting on the shadow I noticed that at the end of the day my shadow still looks fresh no creases and it really looks nice with my brown eyes and I also love that it comes with a how...
Revlon Photoready Eyeshadow

19 reviews

I love this eyeshadow it stays on all day and doesn't fade away. I think it fantastic that a primer, colour and highlighter are all included in one kit.
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Smokey Eye

6 reviews

I usually use drugstore shadow and wanted to try this for its shimmery effects. It's horrible quality. Cover girl nude palettes are far superior to this product. Came with a weird angled foam applicator that I thought would be fairly good for applying like a liner to my lower...