Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
941-960 of 1574

e.l.f. Cosmetics Essential Smudge Pot

6 reviews

Shiny and shimmery cream eye shadow. Really brightens the eyes while the cream formula rests naturally on the skin. Super easy to use and blend. And its elf so super inexpensive.
Lise Watier Ombre Souffle Supreme Eye Shadow

5 reviews

Un ombre solo de Lise Watier , qui s'applique avec les doigts , tellement légère et douce au toucher . La texture est entre une crème et une poudre d'une telle finesse , la couleur rose thé de velours est une teinte vraiment naturelle vous aurez l'impression de ne pas être...
Elizabeth Arden Beautiful Color Eye Shadow Quad - Chic Browns

2 reviews

I bought this eye shadow a long time ago when I was first starting to wear make up. The colours are beautiful and warm and neutral. The case was nice and compact too and shut really tight so you didn't have to worry about it opening up in your purse.
e.l.f. Cosmetics prism eyeshadow naked

1 review

Great eyeshadow and I love the colours, perfect for anything from a natural look to a smokey eye.
Sonia Kashuck Eye On Neutral Eye Shadow Palette

2 reviews

I so love this product so much very very very beautiful shimmery just the way I like it and the colors are perfect my kinda colors shimmery sands it last I buy 3 of them when I go to the store cuz for some reason they are always out
Revlon PhotoReady Primer & Shadow

5 reviews

This primer was a miracle. The primer filled any fine lines and pores and left my skin feeling soft smooth and flawless. Make up application after the primer was simple and smooth I can’t go a day without this primer.
Elizabeth Arden Color Intrigue Eyeshadow- Smoke 23

1 review

This is a great neutral eye shadow for evening looks. I do not get many opportunities to wear dark makeup but when I go out I use this Smoke color to create the perfect smokey eye. The shadow itself is fairly pigmented. Not quite as pigmented as the eye shadows from mac. But...
100% Pure Eye Creamstick

1 review

Each beautifully packaged tube of the cream-sticks are travel friendly and easily slip into your purse or gym bag. The formula is rich, creamy and has a high pigmentation. Some of the shadows have a slight shimmer to them. Absolutely gorgeous! The shadows will not tug on the...
FACES COSMETIC EYESHADOW

1 review

Faces cosmetic is comparable to Mac eyeshadow. The texture is buttery soft, pigmentation is insane and the price is right. Picture speak for itself.
MAC Warm Neutral Palette

2 reviews

This is my favourite eyeshadow palette! I love every single colour in this palette which is rare for an eyeshadow palette (usually there are a few odd colours you don't like in a palette). These shadows are very pigmented and go on smoothly. There is a good balance between...
Maybelline Chocolate mousse eye shadow

3 reviews

Nothing really special but it does the job. Seems to need a lot more primer to stay on though. If I don't use a ton of primer with this it only stays for 3 hours on my oily skin. I love the color so I use it regardless.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Baked

3 reviews

I won't buy it again but I'm sure i will use it? Nothing special, not overly pigmented so you need quite a bit. Nothing to write home about it have had better for a simular price.
mica beauty cosmetic

4 reviews

this is not a very good brand. i recieved their bronze gel eye shadow and didnt have it more than 2 weeks and it went rock hard. i tried contacting them bout it but they refuse to do nothing.... not even an apology
PUR Minerals Eye Polish Base and Top Coat

4 reviews

I really didn't enjoy this product at all...which left me pretty shocked because I love PUR Minerals products. In the container, the shadows seem to be highly pigmented and shimmery! Which led me to believe the product would apply the same way on my lids. When applied, the...
L'Oreal Paris LA COULEUR INFALLIBLE Eye Shadow

1 review

I received this shadow, in Amber Rush, as a gift and it is fantastic. The colour is really intense so a little goes a long way. I apply it over Urban Decay Shadow Primer Potion and it doesn't budge all day. Will be purchasing other colours in the future.
e.l.f. Studio Prism Eyeshadow in Sunset

3 reviews

This is a beautiful summer palette. The colours are lovely in the pan and on the eye. Pigmentation, whether applied by finger or flat brush, is really great for such a low price, but you definitely need a primer or setting spray to prevent fallout and prolong longevity. I've...
makeup geek crupt

1 review

Excellant price and its just as good as Mac eye shadows!!!
Annabelle Twistup Eyeshadow Crayon

2 reviews

Annabelle Twistup Eyeshadow Crayon; I have used off my mother .... it's okay but still after using better makeup you become picky great color, smoothness, but simply color does not last on your eye lids as long as other brands that you pay a lot more more.
Milani Shadow Eyez

1 review

This is a great eye shadow pencil in golden bronze that I actually found at the Dollar store. I have saw this same brand at other stores for more than $1. It is a very subtle bronze color that last all day without smudging. It is easy to apply and doesn't tug at the eye area.
Quo beauty contest box

1 review

I love shoppers drug mart brand , this kit comes with 13 eye shadows, 4 gel eyeliners, 2 Big blushes & applicators all for $30.00. I love the colours they stay on all day. And it's in a neat little jewelry type box.