Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
961-980 of 1574

Wet N Wild Color Icon Single Shadow

6 reviews

Wet N Wild makes a fantastic quality eye shadow, I love that these are single eye shadows that way when you are only wearing a certain colour in a day you can just bring that one eye shadow with you on the go rather then a whole eye shadow pallette. Nice colours to choose from...
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Eternal Black

1 review

I love using this black when I don't want a matte because it's not overly pigmented which makes it easy to work with, plus there isn't as much fallout when you use your finger to pack it on
Quo Spring 2015 Collection

3 reviews

Quo is my stand by, I use it almost every day. Especially love the multi colour sets. Matte or shimmer doesn't matter, it lasts all day. Highly recommend their brushes to apply their blush and eye-shadow. Usually buy mine around Christmas time, best prices.
Essence Smokey Eyes Set

1 review

These tiny little palettes include three shades of shadow each with an applicator to create a simple, easy smoky eye in a few steps. I’m of the mentality you don’t need twenty different eyeshadows to create one look! This little palette includes the essentials which are a...
Julep Feels Like Velvet Full-Coverage Eyeshadow Duo

1 review

Currently Julep offers five different duos that you can pick from. I ordered the duo "5th Ave & Broadway," which was a nice combo of a champagne shimmer and a matte blush pink. At first I was disappointed in the product because of how I applied it. Normally I use a brush to...
Quo eyeshadow quad in 'sandbar'

2 reviews

Was given this as a gift and must say I’m impressed by these shadows! They definitely last an eight hour day! Highly pigmented! They do not crease or fall around the eyes!
Macy's Impulse Beauty Artistry Palette

1 review

The palette is beautiful with tons of colors to create glamorous eye looks for both day and night.
Lancôme Pose Eye Shadow

1 review

My favourite eyeshadow - this looks good anytime of year. Looks great worn alone as a bit of gold shimmer or worn with heavy eyeliner for a more dramatic effect.
COVERGIRL Liquiline Blast Eyeliner

29 reviews

This covergirl eyeliner works so so good. I have it in black brown and blue! I wear it every day . It never smudges or smears. I love it so very much!
Milani Eyeshadow Pencil in Golden Bronze

1 review

This is an awesome eye shadow crayon type pencil in a bronze color. I happened to find it at the dollar store and it's made in Germany. It's not a metallic bronze that makes you look like a clown, but a subtle hue of it. I like to use it sparingly on the outer rim of my lash...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Brightening Eye Color in Ethereal

1 review

I found this awesome product from the Dollar Tree for $1. I love using it on my eyelids. I mostly use the white color to highlight my brow bone and it makes my eyelids look more lifted. I use the darker shade to put across the upper middle of the eyelid and that opens my eyes...
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Nude

3 reviews

Mine is Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Shadow & Liner - Nude. I purchase with 40% discount and quality is so so. If I purchased with regular price, I would think waste of money.
Rimmel London Glam'Eyes HD Eye Shadow

3 reviews

Rimmel London Glam'Eyes HD Eye Shadow, Brick Lane: LOVE this eye shadow, worth every penny and great colors that last!
Tarte Poppy Picnic Amazonian Clay Eye Palette

2 reviews

I enjoy all colours in this palette, the blush is a very bright pink which I love, this palette is great for everyday wear. I will repurchase this palette.
Milani Bella Eyes Gel Powder Eyeshadow

7 reviews

I love the Milani Bella eyeshadows the price is right, the colours are beautiful, you can use them with a dry or wet brush depending on what type of look your going for. Wetting the brush really gives the satin finish and helps with the pigment. I love these!
Avon 8-in-1 Eye Palette

27 reviews

Overall great product from avon a variety of colourful palettes to choose from and the colours seem to be long wearable and durable to keep a nice even tone for hours after applying to your eyes would recommend
Clinique Color Surge Eye Shadow Duo

2 reviews

This eye shadow is ok .. its small and great for the purse but not worth the month i rather buy something with more product in it but color is awesome .just needs to have a little more for your buck .
Daring by day eye & cheek colour palette

1 review

The colors they choose to put together just always make sense to me, and the formulas are top notch. They use a little more color than Bobbi, but they don’t go over the top.
Hard Candy Naturally Gorgeous Top Ten Eye Shadow Collection 524

6 reviews

This is actually a really nice drugstore eye shadow palette. Has very pretty neutral tones and shades in it and the shadows are pretty pigmented. I like the packaging too. But definitely doesn't compare to UD or KVD.
H&M;Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

Priced very reasonably and of decent quality, I have not yet tried all the colours in the palette but of those I have tried, the pay off is OK. The colour isn't very saturated, so you'd need to either use a bit of water to darken it or try adding more. But it stood up well...