Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1001-1020 of 1574

MAC Faerie Whispers collection

1 review

Very affordable.But my first impressions? Shine. Various degrees of it, from subtle sheen to lustrous metallic.
Haughty Cosmetics Eye Shadow - Ambition

1 review

I really actually like this colour to give my eyes a bit of umph when I really don't want to wear a lot of colour on my face - it's more of a Nude colour. It isn't overly powdery, therefore it stays where it is put - always important! And being made from all natural...
Sephora Pantone Marsala Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

This is an awesome palette , i love the color and it is very pigmented ! It had a little bit of fall out but its so pigmented so you have a great result
So Susan intense eye shadow palette with coated pigments

2 reviews

I really like the more neutral shades of this palette - especially the pink! The powder sticks nicely to my eyes without leaving a crease mid way through the day, and the powder doesn't leave the brush for other regions of my face as I'm applying it. It is a bit pricey though...
Urban Decay Eye Shadow in Sin

4 reviews

This is my favorite eyeshadow! I love the color, is great for all over lid color, it stays all day. I love the brand Urban Decay, it never disappoints. Not a lot of fallout.
Lorac Mega Pro Palette

4 reviews

This eyeshadow is wonderful. It goes on so smooth like butter and stays all day. The colors are amazing and are easily blendable. Each shade complements the next and can be used with a brush or your hands. Definitely give the lorac shadows a try,you won't be sorry.
NYX Cosmetics Love in Rio Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

Love this combination of colours. Go on silky. Last all day. I use the darker brown to color in my eyebrows.
MAC Cosmetics Pigments

3 reviews

These pigments are beautiful they are very bright and the color is very rich and shimmery.you will sparkle all day with this product.i love the packaging and Mac is very affordable and offers free shipping online. It is a great product for a night out I love anything that...
Mary Kay Be Radiant Baked Powder in Dawn

1 review

Probably one of the truest to the pallet eye shadows that I own. I wish it were a little less sparkly sometimes but it's a nice touch.
L'oreal Nude Palette 2

2 reviews

The colors looks really good. The eyeshadow texture are powder, but the color stay for the day without any trouble!
COVERGIRL Queen Collection 1-Kit Eye Shadow Vintage

1 review

The Vintage color of this Covergirl Queen Collection Eye Shadow is beautiful! I love earth tones and this one definitely fits the bill. Applies easily with the included applicator. Great size to fit in my makeup bag and carry with me when I go out for a night on the town. Highly...
Eyemei Glitters

2 reviews

I got these Eyemei Glitters a couple years ago from a friend. Back then I wasn't as into makeup as I am now, so I tossed them in a bag and forgot about them. Well fast forward to now, I just pulled them out to do swatches and OMG they were SOOOOO beautiful! I mean the pigment...
NYX Hot Singles Eyeshadow

4 reviews

These are such good dupes for MAC eyeshadows! And I love the little bow on NYX eyeshadow packaging.
Tarte Be MATTEnificent

2 reviews

TARTE is my favourite company for matte eyeshadows. Super pigmented and easy to blend out without losing too much pigment.
Elektra Cosmetics

1 review

I am a burlesque dancer and this is by far the best product out there. there is nothing like it.
The Nude Tude Palette by The Balm

4 reviews

I love the colours in this pallet, and the eye shadow is very good quality. Definitely recommend.
city color white gold

2 reviews

I received this in an Ipsy bag awhile ago and the colour looks amazing. I figured I'd use it up quickly on those days when i didn't want a lot of makeup, but i love a sweep of gold on those days, but because i have oily eyelids and this is a lightweight cream formula, i just get...
Claire's pastel eye shadow

3 reviews

I knew that this was not what I wanted it to be! I knew that this was going to be bad as soon as I saw the packaging, but I gave it a try. Nope, I wanted to like it because of the holo colors but then the questions of what makes a good makeup started to overpower the colors it...
Coastal Scents Revealed 2 Palette

7 reviews

Ok, I own it's predecessor Coastal Scents 1. This is a fantastic encore to that. Offers many pigmented eyeshadows in matte and Shimmer. I can't say enough about the value of this eyeshadow palette. I love the first one and love this just as much. Very similar colors ranging from...
Julep Sweep Eyeshadow Palette: Neutrals

5 reviews

This is something that I use every single day this is my favorite palette it has all my favorite colors except for the darkest one I don't really like it but I will wear it. this stuff is so soft it applies great it comes off nicely, definitely does the job supposed to do I...