Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1021-1040 of 1574

Nyx adorable palette

4 reviews

From one makeup lover to another this palettes was great. Pulled off the looks I needed and wanted Definitely would recommend this to my fellow makeup queens
essence quattro eyeshadow

2 reviews

I have this in the colour Over The Taupe. I find these shadows very creamy and with good pigmentation. The colours in this palette are great everyday neutrals. It's hard to believe that these are so inexpensive as the quality is excellent!
Flower Beauty Makeup

3 reviews

So loving the new lip glosses. They claim to be plumping but I just feel the gloss. But it is not sticky at all and lasts so long for a gloss. It leaves some small glitter flexes and its beyond flattering.
Milani Everyday Eyes

1 review

I bought the Milani Everyday Eyes palette in Earhty Elements and the neutrals.the earthy elements isn't too bad, but I did not like the neutrals . I found that instead of being a nice shimmer or satin finish, the shadows seem to have small flakes of glitter. No matter how I...
Beaute Basics Sahara Gold Chubby Eye Pencil

2 reviews

This product is honestly amazing. I've been using it for around 5 months now, and I don't think I can ever stop buying it now! It last's so long and has so much product in it. It is also such a gorgeous colour and has a cute little sparkle to it. It is absolutely amazing and...
Lancôme Paris Color Focus Duo

3 reviews

Loved using these colors for my eyes, including the black which I color my eyebrows with it doesnt make it dark just light
Lush Sophisticated

2 reviews

This is such an amazing eye shadow! Feels cooling on the eyelids, and the colour pay off is amazing. This lasts such a long time with no creasing or fading, like with some other cream shadows. I use this as a base sometimes and it really makes other colours stand out. Love this...
Hard Candy Natural Eye Palette

5 reviews

Cette palette est parfaite pour un look naturel. Elle n'est pas très pigmenté mais c'est quand même bien pour un petit look discret. Les couleurs sont très jolie.
Wet N Wild Eyeshadow Palette in Comfort Zone

6 reviews

I love this palette, while I'm not a huge fan of green eyeshadow, this palette makes it easy to incorporate it into everyday looks. The shadows are very pigmented and easy to blend plus you really cannot go wrong with how inexpensive it is. Go buy this palette I promise you...
Stila Eye Shadow Pan

3 reviews

This is a great eye shadow brand they wear well and they are nicely pigmented. You do get a slight bit of fall out so beware of that.
Arbonne Eye Shadow

3 reviews

I love my arbonne eye shadow pallet. I have very sensitive skin and this is one of the products that I can use. The pallet I bought is cute on the outside but also has adorable and practical neutrals on the inside. It applies well and with a bit of primer lasts a while day!
Mac Paint Pot in Perky

1 review

This eyeshadow is a nice, neutral, coral pink. I was hoping it would be good as an everyday colour that would brighten my eyes. However, the colour barely shows up on my skin. You would need to apply a lot of it (and a lot of blending) before it looks decent. Not impressed with...
Micabella Cosmetics Eye Shadow

5 reviews

Being a trans woman it is very important as all women to buy the best products for a fair price. I buy mica belle eye shadow, nice and easy to use, the colours are very sexy yet classy. They do not Matt or cake on your face they feel wonderful. Wish we had a store closer.
Soho Graffiti Sugar Box 8 colors smoky eye-shadows palette

1 review

Eye-shadow palette is very cute. So are the shades. Besides the great palette, I love the texture and appearance of the eye-shadow - matte but at the same time very pigmented. Very easy to apply and feels so light, almost silky. Last a good while without fading. I love how on...
Pacifica Natural Mineral Coconut Eye Shadow

3 reviews

This is my go-to for a nice day look... this product last all day worth little or no fallout while applying. Just really disappointed that they discon my favorite trio... which worked perfectly withy eye color and skin tone
NARS Matte Eye Shadow in Coconut Grove

2 reviews

This shade absolutely takes my breath away. I use it almost every day, and I think this would be a great contour shade to use on the face for someone with a darker skin tone!
Shu Uemura Brave Beauty Eye Palette in Orange

1 review

What the Orange Palette has taught me is that bright orange CAN be worn in an everyday look without looking like I only belong on a catwalk. The shadows in the palette were so deliciously soft and pigmented and I used no primer in my swatches so what you see, is what you get...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Little Black Book Eye Shadow Palette

2 reviews

Before I bought the product, I was told that Elf creates horrible makeup products. I still wanted to give it a try so I did. I bought the black book on sale for $5 at TJ MAX. It was definitely worth it. I found the colors to be very nice and applied on my skin so easily. I have...
Maybelline Glam Eyes Eye Shadow

4 reviews

I love these eyeshadows! The formula is excellent and they are super pigmented.
Joe Fresh Style Eye Shadow

1 review

i bought it because it was on sale (fairly cheap already, can get them at Superstore) But they didn't blend well, I wouldn't buy it again but it's a good cheap product for what it is.