Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1041-1060 of 1574

Mary Kay Be Radiant Baked Powder in Dusk

1 review

Bought this to complete the Dusk & Dawn set, I wasn't a huge fan of the red wine/ burgundy color (I'm to fair skinned) but the browns were nice.
Revlon ColorStay 16 Hour Eye Shadow

8 reviews

I love the fact that these eyeshadows are very easy to apply. It goes on so smooth when using the right applicators or brushes. The colors are not as vibrant but it sure does stay on as the name says!
Barry m dazzle dust

4 reviews

An easy high street competitor for MAC's pigment, Dazzle Dust is an eyeshadow, a highlighter, and would even make a great nail powder too. Ensure you fix this Dazzling dust down with a cream product or Vaseline to hold it in place, or use a base and top coat if using as nail...
LORAC Unzipped Palette

6 reviews

This palette is just ok, in its prime days (like 2016) it was amazing and all anyone could talk about. These days there are just better formulas out there. It has a lot of kickback when you dip your brush in it, which can be annoying and makes for a messy palette. It does blend...
stila cosmetics In the Light Eye Shadow Palette

5 reviews

Beautiful colours in this palette. Although I wish there were some more matte colours. I also only use a few shades from this palette but the shadows are great quality and look beautiful on! I would not purchase it again only because I would like to try something new.
L.A. COLORS 6 COLOR EYESHADOW PALETTE

2 reviews

These shadows are surprisingly good. They're super inexpensive, very pigmented and last well. I have several pallets and they have lasted a long time. Cant beat the quality for the price.
Dior Couleure Couture Colours Eye Shadow

2 reviews

Got three for my birthday and the consistency and pigment is sooooo gorgeous! Definitely worth the high end label.
Lili Rouge Eye Touch

1 review

Eye touch! is a loose powder eye shadow with really strong pigments and that s why I love it! The color You see is the color You ll get. It can be use on your cheeks and lips as well, it s also use for body painting since You can use it demp. Intense pigments that last at least...
Coastal Scents 88 Palette

3 reviews

All the eyeshadows from Coastal Scents has never ceased to please. Using their primer and any of the shadows have allowed me to maintain a brilliant makeup routine with colours and shine that last all day! Amazing colour pallettes with a wide choice of complimentary colours to...
Rob Scheppy for 'Tini Beauty Eye Shadow - Pearl Fizz

1 review

I like my make up to be subtle some days, and Pearl Fizz helps with that. It's a nice dark shade of cream (super light shade of brown?), just perfect for those days where you don't want to look all dolled up. It goes on quite nicely with my eyeshadow brush or finger, and stays...
Smashbox Master Class Palette III Color & Contour

2 reviews

It went on smoothly, and really helped enhance my features. I'm hard to please but this one really impressed me. I found the colour schemes to work with almost any colour.
Almay Shadow Softies

5 reviews

Quite possibly the worst eyeshadow that I've ever tried. I used the colour Creme Brulee. It was hardly pigmented at all. It was difficult to pick up with any sort of brush. The only way I could grab any colour at all was to rub my finger into the product. The only thing I'd use...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Duo Eye Shadow

1 review

I love this eyeshadow! It goes on smoothly, the two colours in each compact blend beautifully and my vegetarian daughter and I both like that the e.l.f. brand is not tested on animals.
tre`StiQue Eye Shadow Crayon

2 reviews

Blends in so well to be a sample wow! I am so glad I found this site this helps me see if things at the store actually work (Fenty beauty) I tried it on a different site for a sample and it works!
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eye Shadow - Leather

4 reviews

I finished my collection of all the colour tattoo shades and leather is super gorgeous!!!
Almay Intense I-color Shimmer-I Trio for Greens

4 reviews

I was quite disappointed with this product. The shadows didn't have much pigment at all. The applicator didn't do much either. The best part of this product was the image that showed you where to apply each shade. Then I took similar colours from other brands of shadows...
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Handwritten

1 review

This is a highly-pigmented shadow that is a MUST-HAVE colour!! It blends so well in the crease for ANY look, and is a real standard in day-to-day makeup looks. It's a pretty deep brown colour so it's perfect in accentuating the crease and outer corner to make your eyes look...
Ulta Eyeshadow

3 reviews

I really like the way these shadows go on. The only downside for me is the colors are fairly light and I feel as if I needed to apply several layers to get the desired color. They last well and have a huge variety of shades. They are frequently on sale and very reasonable
lise watier sublime souflee eyeshadow

1 review

Goes on light and can be layered for light looks or intense appeal. Costs a lot up front but lasts and is very worth it. Takes zero seconds to put on, lasts all day with minimal creasing - not common with most liquid eyeshadows. Definitely worth trying!
L'oreal Hip Metallic Duo Shadow

1 review

Great color pairs, pretty comparable to most other drug store eye shadow.