Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1061-1080 of 1574

Almay Intense i-color Powder Shadow Smoky-i for Hazels

3 reviews

I love this little shadow compact. The gray is highly pigmented and there is no fallout. There is a subtle glitter that is mixed well and doesn't get in your eyes. I rarely use the purple color, but that is okay, because I bought it for the gray and silver. The silver is a...
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Taupe

1 review

I love the formula of these shadows, but I thought this one was a tad bit patchy and not as pigmented as it could be.
MAC Cosmetics Desert Camoflage Full Face Kit

1 review

I love this palatte loads! It has great neutral colours which I love. They are super pigmented and pretty. It also comes with a creme blush which I don't use. It is a dark brownish orange colour which doesn't suit my skin but it is pigmented and creamy. Overall I would recommend...
coastal scents eye shadow

2 reviews

These shadows come in fun palettes - whether you're looking for bright and vibrant, nudes and neutrals, or in-between - there's a palette for you! I love that I can tone up or down my colours without much thought, and from only one eyeshadow package. It goes on nice and...
e.l.f. Cosmetics smokey eyes

1 review

Nice little palette for under 5$ the colours are nice but you do need to use a lot for the colours to pop ( the white specially) .
Gosh effect powder spa

1 review

This powder is super pigmented. That being said it's also a light sky blue. It's a gorgeous colour but not one that flatters my skin tone. A little goes a long way with this powder and it lasts a very long time. It's also extremely shimmery so use sparingly!
Maybelline Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quad

4 reviews

This is a good little palette. Great mostly Matte, some have a bit Shimmer in shades. Great for day or night looks. I think personally think that the shades are great for all season. The formulation is great. Goes on and stays on. Not chalky or dusty. Will definitely be...
GOSH Cosmetics Mineral Colour Pigments

3 reviews

This mineral eye shadow is very intense. I purchased to try it out and it is a gives a beautiful pigmented color on my eyes. Little goes along way.
Too Faced Candy Bar Palette

2 reviews

LOVE the smell of this eye palette! These shadows are VERY SMOOTH. They feel like you are rubbing butter on your eyelids. Super smooth, they do not crease, and they look great!
Too Faced La Belle Carousel Palette

1 review

This 2014 Holiday palette is worth every penny. Gorgeous colours..comes with a tutorial too which I absolutely love!
Sonia Kashuck Eyeshadow

1 review

this little palette has all the colours I need and them some for a day or night look, satisfied with the pigment
BeYu star lights eye shadow

1 review

My party/holiday season make up accessory. Gives a nice shimmer. Powder, very easy to use and apply. May be applied more than once.
ArtDeco Eye shadow single #293

1 review

I like ArtDeco cosmetics a lot, I find them to be really good quality. This one is single eye shadow with nice shimmer and light pink/violet color. Long lasting and good looking.
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Shadow & Liner

28 reviews

This little stick is amazing! I didn't think it was gonna show up as good as it did ! I am very surprised! I will most definitely be buying more of these little things in the future!
Soho electric eyeshadow

1 review

This eyeshadow is soo pigmented to the point of looking like a facepaint. I don't really have a use for such a bright shadow.
essence All About Paradise Eye Shadow Palette

5 reviews

The colors in the pallet are so pretty and the pigment is very buildable but the fall out is insane! I feel like there is more shadow on my face by the end of application than on my eyelid!
stila cosmetics Eye Shadow

3 reviews

I purchased the Stila eyeshadow in kitten color. It is the perfect color for a natural but enhanced look! It has just the right amount of sparkle so that your eyes do not look overdone. It brings out the contour of your eyes and highlights at the right spots. Eyes look...
Lise Watier Aurora Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

the colour of the aurora palette are simply beautiful !!! They are nice and bright but without been too much . It is really smooth to apply and doesn't require a lot of eyeshadow to get a nice colour ( like the gold) .
L.A. Colors Haute & Sweet Pallette

2 reviews

This would make nice gifts for young ladies. There's a lot of colors to choose from.
Shiseido Simmering Cream Eye Colour

3 reviews

I have this in a vanilla yellow color, a light brown and a dark brown. This stuff is satiny smooth, weightless once dry and the best part is it stays put without a primer. I have the yellow which I use as a base color as it's pretty close to my natural color. I like the light...