Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1141-1160 of 1574

mica mineral eye shadow

1 review

Goes on fabulous and lasts all day
Urban Decay Eye Shadow in Skin

1 review

This is a gorgeous matte nude eye shadow. Because I have very fair skin, it appears as a light mocha shade on my lids, but for most people it would probably be a good nude base colour. The formula is very high quality, and used with the Urban Decay primer, it stays all day...
josie maran coconut watercolor eyeshadow

1 review

This product is really great. You can layer it over other colors or use it alone or as a highlighter. Needs to be shaken up for quite awhile before applying. Still love this product.
HARD CANDY POPPIN PIGMENTS

1 review

hey come in cute little shaker style bottles, you just uncap and shake the pigments out. Before I opened the package I could see some loose glitter floating around and clinging to the inside of the package :( These are pretty much an unpigmented glittery fall-out mess, while the...
e.l.f. Beauty Must Haves

1 review

This little set is very handy, Its great for beginners starting off on makeup, the shadows are very pigmented, The liner is my go to liner now, but the lashes that come with this palette aint really good quality. I ended up giving them to a friend who wanted to practice fake...
Laura Mercier Eyeshadow in Espresso Bean

1 review

A beautiful black eyeshadow perfect for layering over eyeliner. Lasts for a long time, especially with primer. Feels smooth and light. highly pigmented.
kozmic colours eyeshadow

2 reviews

This eyeshadow palette reminds me of the Urban Decay Naked 2 palette. It has many neutral shades and I see myself being able to use all of the colours. This palette comes with 18 shimmery colours and I wish that it came with at least a few matte colours. Initial pigmentation is...
Avon Color Trend Roll On Eye Shadow Ultramarine

3 reviews

Avon Color Trend Roll On Eye Shadow Ultramarine Reviews: I was not a huge fan of this product. I don't like the way it went on and looked very clumpy not smooth.
Too Faced Country Nashville Nudes Eye Shadow Collection

1 review

Too Face palettes are usually good/great, but this one is AWFUL. The colors are pretty, but they don't come together. You couldn't do your eye makeup with just this palette. The shades all contain big chunks of gritty glitter. They aren't pigmented at all and they're sooo dry...
NYX Love in Paris Eye Shadow Palette

3 reviews

I own two of these palettes and I find the colours very hit and miss. Many of the colours are smooth and highly pigmented, however there are also some that are chalky and apply horribly. I intend to depot these palettes and only keep the colours that I actually use.
NYC Individual Eyes

19 reviews

I get compliments on my eye makeup constantly since switching to NYC individual eyes. It really makes my blue eyes pop. I also like that there is a pic on the back how to properly apply the shadow.
Sahara Gold Beaute Basics

1 review

I received this in my Ipsy bag this month so thankfully I didn't pay for it. It is very sheer, so sheer in fact, it almost just looks like I have no eyeshadow on at all. Even underneath another color, it has no effect. The brand itself is pretty expensive, so I'd assume the...
Avon 2 Pod Eyeshadow

19 reviews

This Avon product is overpriced for what it is. It does not last when applied, comes off in a couple of hours. I would definitely not buy this again. Waste of money
Hard Candy Eye Shadow Palette

10 reviews

I bought this Hard Candy Eyeshadow Palette - Top Ten Trendsetter in "Guilty Pleasure" and was quite disappointed with it ☹️ when I saw it, I thought I needed it in my life, fell in love with the shades and the endless sparkles✨ Sadly, when I applied them, they were more of...
Lancôme Paris Showstopper Style Eye Shadow

1 review

Showstopper Style comes in four colours, a shimmery gold, a chocolate brown, a moca brown and a tan colour inlaid with a gold shimmer. It truely is a 'show stopper', I have blue/grey eyes and when I wear these colour my eyes are gorgeous!!! (not bragging about myself, but this...
Clinique All About Shadow Singles Soft Matte

1 review

Such a great product. Creamy and dreamy, this shadow adds a beautiful colour to your eyes and glides on easily. A must have for any collection. Fabulous colours and reasonably priced so it's easy to own several :)
NYX The Natural Shadow Palette

2 reviews

I love NYX, but I gotta admit this palettte is letting me down. The shades are not very intenses, the colours are VERY natural, in like, almost not there on your eyes. Still not the worst I've tried, but I won't buy it again.
The Body Shop Eyeshadow in 05

2 reviews

I bought this eyeshadow on sale and have been using it ever since. The one I have has four colors and can easily be blended together and last fairly well. The four colors are very verstile and easily go with about anything too
ARTDECO Long Lasting Eyeshadow Stick

1 review

There are 8 shades in total ranging from fairly neutral to more adventurous colours like purple and blue. They not only stick around for 8 hours without any primer, but have gorgeous pigmentation and effortlessly glide on to the eyelid. They were so creamy that I was convinced...
Wet N Wild Single Eyeshadow

2 reviews

I purchased the shadows thinking they were at a reasonable price of $2, but it turns out although I saved some money on the shadows they didn’t work very well on my eyes! I felt like I had to continuously pat the eyeshadow on 5-6 times before I got some pigmentation...The...