Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1161-1180 of 1574

Bourjois Paris Little Round Pot

1 review

My quest for the perfect metallic eye shadow ended when Bourjois Paris’ Little Round Pot Eyeshadow in Brun Irréel landed on my desk. I used the conveniently stowed sponge-tip applicator to test out the new find. And it was love at first stroke of the brush. The baked...
Sephora Collection Sand Illusions Baked Eye Shadow Palette

3 reviews

Probably the worst eye-shadow pallet I have bought, it was expensive the color payoff was below average, I applied it wet/dry and either one was bad, save your money
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Vex

2 reviews

This is a great day to day eye shadow. It lasts very well throughout the day and is a great buy!
Lorac Pro 2 Palette

1 review

The colours in this palette are amazing. Very different, with all cool shades. I enjoy how unique the colours are and the high quality of the pigmentation. This does have quite a bit of fallout, and the shadows are fairly soft so you should be gentle when picking up product.
Annabelle Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Aura

1 review

I LOVE THIS EYESHADOW. its so settle yet so nice, its smooth, very pigmented. I love it so much i already finished one and have to buy another
Diorshow Fusion Mono in Météore

1 review

Well... I adore this eye shadow. It is smooth, creamy and perfect. You can apply it with your finger tips or the applicator it comes with. Add water for a bolder look. You can also get this in the eye shadow primer which is a perfect base for all eye looks. This product can be...
NYX Nude Matte Shadow

3 reviews

It is not the most pigmented eyeshadow but it’s not invisible either. It’s a great eyeshadow for someone who is not the best at blending like me. The colour is really nice and i can just put in on by itself for a natural look.
Almay I-colour powder trio for blue eyes

3 reviews

This little pallet was easy to use to create unique looks. I thought that the colors did a great job accentuating my eye color and skin tone. This is a great drug store staple piece for your makeup collection.
Revlon CustomEyes

1 review

I have the 005 Gold Spun eye shadow. There are 5 different colors from black, brown, light brown, gold, and white. The black and brown are pretty pigmented and comes out beautifully when I put them on. The rest except for the white are pretty pigmented as well but not as much as...
Mary Kay Eye Palette in Sapphire Noir

1 review

Yeah…I love this. Even with the fallout I got from the grey shadow, it was totally fine as a liner when I used it damp. The trio of purple shadows is honestly like nothing I have in my arsenal and that is a tough thing to say! The quality of the shadows was smooth and soft...
Divergent Makeup Palette

2 reviews

Good quality and textures Stays on for awhile doesn't smudge to easily Good quality and textures Stays on for awhile doesn't smudge to easily Good quality and textures Stays on for awhile doesn't smudge to easily
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Club

1 review

This is a shadow for day or evening. Provides an Iridescent glow of several colours. Must have! Looks great with any eye colour.
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Omega

1 review

Omega is a taupe coloured eyeshadow from MAC. I initially purchased this product after it was recommended by a MUA for my brows. It works perfectly on my blonde brows and fills them in nicely. Works especially well when used in conjunction with a brow pencil.
essence Eye Shadow in Cookies & Cream

3 reviews

The colors are very easy to apply on and they are good for everyday makeup look. A very basic piece to have in the makeup bag. Good for people who are new to make up.
Maybelline Eyestudio eyeshadow #80 Sinful

2 reviews

This eye shadow does the job - not crazy about it but the colors are nice and work well together.
Mary Kay Emerald Noir Palette

1 review

The Emerald Noir palette didn’t translate quite as well onto my eyes in terms of wow factor. I felt like the swatches were amazing and then on my eyes not so much. The shadows blended out quite easily which meant that I had to go in a few times with the same colours over and...
CoverGirl Flamed Out Shadow Pencil

2 reviews

I bought all the colours after Hunger Games came out. The glide right on and you can add a little or a lot and the colours stay pretty true throughout the day. Creamy consistency on the lid. Easy removal. By the end of the night only the places that I had liner are still...
Smashbox Wondervision Mega Palette 2013

1 review

Shadows have great pigment and are super soft. Mix of matte and shimmers. Blushes have great colour but a little dry of a formula. Bronzer is matte. Blends very well.
NYC Sparkle Eye Dust Pink Champagne

1 review

I love this stuff, always wear it every day! I only put the price for the review as average, because it was a gift from a friend. I still highly recommend it though!
Coastal Scents Winterberry Palette

1 review

I purchased this eye palette as my first purchase from this company. For the price $12.95, it is amazing. The colours are vibrant and last all day. I will purchase more makeup from this company.