Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1181-1200 of 1574

stila cosmetics Magnificent Metals Foil Finish Eye Shadow

3 reviews

STILA COSMETICS MAGNIFICENT METALS FOIL FINISH EYE SHADOW is well, just plain awesome!!. The pigment and quality is beyond words. It looks so metallic yet blendable. So easy to apply!
essence Ticket To Paradise Eye Shadow

1 review

In colour Tropical Heat. Great sturdy container. Gorgeous gold flecked creamy eyeshadow. Stays on really well and you can layer it easily to get a stronger effect. Very summery.
Eddie funkhouser hyper real eye color palette

1 review

I got this in a want able box and it worked great..made real nice smokey eyes too I was pleased with this oroduct
Bone bell powder eye shadow

1 review

Cafe shade is my everyday go to shadow. I use it to cover my entire lid. It's the perfectly sheer but with a lovely rich of colour to use as a base for other shades. Great for the base of a smoky eye. Even on its own it's nice. Makes the inside corner of my eyes pop like crazy...
Maybelline ExpertWear Eyeshadow Quads in Amethyst Smokes

3 reviews

I like the way it has a colour pallatte somewhat. Easy to apply, and stays on for a while :) Does not cost very much
Bellure Eye Shadow with almond oil (shade 27)

1 review

Cheaper end eye shadow. I liked the colors. But quality is lacking. Will have to reapply and shades are kinda pale when applied.
Laura mercier Eyeshadow in Vanilla Nuts

1 review

My most used eyeshadow. Great for daily use. Is a creamy light beige-white color that goes on smoothly and stays on. I would definitely recommend.
Luminelle by Yves Rocher in rose (pink)

1 review

This is a beautiful eyeshadow that is a shimmery pink. Can also be used as a highlighter for cheeks, under eyebrows and face. Does need re-application after several hours wear. The 3.3grams of product lasts a very long time.
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Shroom

1 review

This is a great eye shadow. The colour is perfect for accenting a smoky eye and blends well with most shadows. It lasts all day and doesn't crease.
Smashbox Eye Shadow Duo

1 review

I can't be without this Smashbox eyeshadow duo. The product is easily applied with a brush, feels silky smooth which, as a 50 plus year old woman, is important as the skin becomes thinner with age. This product stays put, looks fabulous, adds dimension and really feels like a...
Hard Candy Eye Def Glitter Eyeshadow

4 reviews

I hated this eye shadow! It is clumpy upon application, doesn't blend well and creases instantly.
Revlon Photo Ready Eye Art Lid + Line + Lash

8 reviews

I'm on the fence. I like the look of the liquid shadow when I apply. The glitter eyeliner is awesome and very glittery. But I found as the day went on it felt sticky and gooey feeling. I think I would buy it again even though it's a bit uncomfortable. The effect is really...
Hard Candy Kaleyedescope Eye Shadow Duo

2 reviews

I purchased this eyeshadow duo in the number 057 peace. I've had this for awhile now and love using it over other eyeshadows or in the corner of my eyes to add a metallic shine. I typically just use my fingers to pat it on. The brown is very pigmented, in the picture I posted I...
Wet n Wild glitter shadow.

1 review

Wet n Wild just released some glitter shadows. I believe there is three shades, I purchased two. I got the bleached 351B which is a clear reflective glitter and the Brass 352B which is a gold glitter. I believe the other shade was a silver glitter. I have to start with the...
Revlon Illuminance Creme Eyeshadow

28 reviews

The shade range on these shadows is very good. There's something available in everything from cool tones to warm tones, very bright to very neutral. They typically come in a quad, with each shade complementing its neighbour. The formula on these cream eyeshadows is very...
Maybelline Expertwear Eye Shadow

15 reviews

Super choix de couleurs surtout si on veux matcher une couleur de vêtement avec ces yeux. Bonne qualité car il reste en place et ne brise pas. Je l'ai échappé une ou deux fois et il est encore intact.
Hard Candy Smoke Out Eyeshadows

3 reviews

I love the packaging of this palette, however I didn't enjoy the colours. They are not very versatile and do not blend well with colours from other palettes. Some of these colours are highly pigmented, while others apply blotchy.
Miss Rose Proffesional make up kit

1 review

very cheap and affordable, comes in little purse size, very handy and good for the money
Wet N Wild Idol Eyes Creme Shadow Pencil

3 reviews

I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THESE PENCILS!! PRO: The color goes on nice, smooth, and bright. Good quality for price. CON: If you rub your eyes they will smear, I recommend using a primer.
The Body Shop Dolly Pastels Palette

1 review

I had the chance to try this palette, which is billed as a "party essential". It definitely lives up to that name, as the colours are very shimmery - perfect for a holiday party look. I think the value is great - four shadow in very pretty packaging for $20. Plus a lovely...