Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1201-1220 of 1574

Shany Cosmetics 40 Count Boutique Shadow Palette

1 review

I purchased the Shany Cosmetics 40 Count Eye Shadow Palette off of Amazon. I was unsure about the quality, as the price was quite low ($15 for 40 shades) but was blown away! The 40 count includes some shimmer eye shadows, as well as some neon and brights, and some more tame...
Sephora eyeshadow in Aspen summit

1 review

A pretty shimmery white eyeshadow. Can be used as highlighter for face as well. Crumbles upon application but otherwise stays on well.
Laura mercier Eyeshadow in Plum Smoke

1 review

An ashy plum colour that appears light purple before application. Goes on with a bit of fall-out so need to apply wet or shake off makeup brush before application. Overall beautiful color that stays on for a good amount of time
e.l.f. Cosmetics Pigment Eye Shadow

1 review

Very difficult to apply because of the small pot. Formula gets everywhere and makes such a mess. Much easier to use a palette.
Smashbox Envy Eye Shadow

1 review

I like this eye shadow in Envy. It's black with a bit of sparkle. I like this brand a lot. Works well
Cle De Peau Beaute Eye Color Quad

1 review

The smell is even luxurious. Using this eyeshadow make me feel like a princess. It's not as pigmented as I thought it would be... Also the colours are too similar in my quad: the green shade and the dark-grey shade in my case and they both give off the same colour. (Both just...
The Body Shop Colour Crush Eyeshadow

2 reviews

I love these eye shadows and the enormous Color Crush range that’s offered. I think they are relatively affordable at $10 a pop and blend beautifully using either fingers or makeup brushes. I have tried three different colours and each one has had wonderful colour payoff...
Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow in Sugar

1 review

Very pigmented, I use it to highlight to my tearducts. It lasts all day, and is a very fair price too.
Too Faced Galaxy Glam Baked Eyeshadow

1 review

I have 2 colours - magenta moon and amber asteroid and I really don't like the dark brown shade in either of these shadows. It is much too dark and overpowering. Pigmentation is great, but they both kind of look the same - dark brown - when applied to the lid. Much more...
Marsk Mineral eyeshadow in Black Comedy

1 review

I like that is a mineral eye shadow but the black colour is not intense and once applied it fades.
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in All That Glitters

12 reviews

This is a great shadow for a quick wash on your lids. I had thought it was discontinued but it looks like Mac recently restocked. It lasts all day with primer, is not irritating and the price is great for the quality.
Clinique Colour Surge Eye Shadow Duo in Like Mink

2 reviews

This is the perfect daytime eyeshadow duo. It is a gorgeous neutral that has a slight shimmer. I have very fair skin and it compliments it well, but I think the colours would be too light on a deeper skin tone. The colour payoff isn't the best, but it does last all day!
SEPHORA COLLECTION Event Entry Palette

1 review

For $7 you can't go wrong with this palette! And its so cute! Black and sparkly gets me every time... not to mention the shadows themselves are gorgeous! They are the perfect colours for me, and they are quite pigmented. I use them everyday now :)
Revlon ColorStay Shadowlinks Eyeshadow

1 review

I love this product so much, they are single eye shadow pallets that connect at either side. This is great for when your travelling and only need a few shadows and it's also good for making costume pallets. And they also come in so many different colours and shades and shimmers.
Sleek iDivine Eyeshadow Palette

4 reviews

I love this palette, the colours are just right for a natural look, perfect for work or a night out. The brush is very handy too! The shadows blend well and they look amazing. I really like the choice of pastel and metalic colours. I would certainly purchase this again!
MAC Cosmetics Extra Dimension Eye Shadow

2 reviews

Lasts ages with great staying power and has great shades. Great for a night out when you are plannign to dance your butt off!
NYC eyeshadow "long sands beach"

1 review

These three colours are gorgeous! I have brown eyes and these shades work perfect. Plus the price is super too! I can do a lighter smoky eye or use the lightest shade to highlight just for an everyday look!
stila cosmetics Smudge Crayon in Antique

1 review

The colour is BEAUTIFUL its like a browny gold it is definitely waterproof and very multipurpose as in you can do a lot with this such as it can be a shadow, a base, a primer, a liner and it comes with a built in sharpener at the end that you can pull out which is very handy.
Claire's Gotta Get Glam Eye Shadow Set

4 reviews

great colors for any skin type
Sweet Recipe Cupcake Eyes

1 review

Two-toned eye shadows baked and infused with pearl to supply sweet shimmer and color Mouth Watering Desserts & Eye Popping Colors