Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1221-1240 of 1574

Bourjois Paris Intense Smoky Eye Shadow Kit

1 review

Available at Shopper's Drug Mart, this handy little palette includes really well described instructions on creating a natural looking smoky eye. Stays on all day, and doesn't crease or bother my contact lenses. It is a beige, brown palette which my make up consultant tells me...
NYX 10 Color Eyeshadow Palette

17 reviews

This product is good. If you are looking for darker colors then this product is for you. It is great for nigh occasions as it has more darker colors of eyeshadows. The shades are quite pigmented!
Balm nude tude eye shadows

1 review

This is the best eye shadow palette out there. Great pigment. Lasts all day. Fantastic swatches for a natural or dramatic look. I cannot recommend this product enough. Very pleased. There is a collection of glitter and matte finishes.
Avon Cosmic Eyeshadow

2 reviews

Loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeee itt! The one I have specifically is 1906 in Cosmic Brown.
Physicians Formula Baked Oatmeal Wet/Dry Eyeshadow

1 review

This is a great eyeshadow, it comes in a little compact with 3 different colored palettes. What I like most about this eyeshadow is that it is a wet or dry formula. If you want a subtle look, apply the eyeshadow dry. Its shimmery and well pigmented. If you want a dramatic look...
Wet 'n Wild Spoiled Brat Eyeshadow

1 review

I bought this to try more than for everyday, the colors are quite extreme. I thought the pink might not be as bright but it is quite true to packaging. I find it hard to make a reasonable look for these colors but is fun to play with. Because the colors are pigmented and I do...
NYX Be Free Palette

2 reviews

I love this palette, great color payoff and texture for a great price!!
Annabelle Cosmetics Twist Up Retractable Eye Shadow Crayon

3 reviews

You get so much product, it doesn't seem like it's gonna finish. I have gold. Goes on smoothly, just glides on. Lasts all day. Very pigmented. I don't even need to use a primer, it just adheres to the eyelids.
wet n wild Color Icon in Silent Treatment

2 reviews

Love the warm, shimmery shades...easy to apply...but crumbled in the container. Still used it but became a bit messy...for the price, it was a score!
e.l.f. Cosmetics Eye Shadows Palette

3 reviews

This is a great palette for the price. Some of the colours are not very pigmented but some are great. They last well with primer.
Revlon ShadowLinks

4 reviews

I love these eyeshadows! I love that you can link them together creating a custom palette and for $4 how can you go wrong. They have great shades that wear well through the day.
QUO Automatic Eye Pencil

3 reviews

These are fun little eye pencils! Definitely a must have for those "Nights Out" or to play with and create different looks. The white one is a great under brow highlighter when blended ocrrectly.
stila cosmetics In the Moment Eye Shadow Palette

3 reviews

worth every penny. beautifully pigmented shadows.
Nicka K Eye Light Crayon - Gold

2 reviews

I love the convenience of Nicka K Eye Light Crayon, on days when I do not feel like doing a whole lot with my eyes this product comes in handy, so I always have it in my makeup bag. They are easy to use, they guide on easily, stays on long, and are very pigmented. The only thing...
L'Oreal Colour Infaillible

4 reviews

il évite à la peau de se briller rapidement , il est assez couvrant , facile à appliquer , il corrige les imperfections , il ne fait pas effet plâtre et laisse un fini matte
almay shadow softies eyeshadow

6 reviews

I purchased this eye shadow in Lilac and I am pleasantly surprised. After hearing and reading mixed reviews I was wary of trying this product, but I was able to purchase it on sale and I am glad I did. It is very smooth and soft when applied and is quite pigmented.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Essential Flawless Eye Shadow Palette

3 reviews

I find that this is great for beginners as it's pretty cheap, and the quality and pigment are great. It is easily blendable, even though the shadows are powdery, but if a good eye primer is used then it should work well and last longer than without one. All of the quads are...
Icing Lavender Lush Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

I bought this palette about a week ago from icing. I like it as it has a wide range of colours to choose from but some of them are a little too sparkly for my taste. The regular price was $14.50 but i got it on sale so i am not complaining ! They do tend to stay on all day and...
Shu Uemura Pret-a-Palette in Pink Hues

1 review

If you are wanting to treat yourself, these palettes are definitely the way to do it with their black-lacquered and sleek packaging, but I know that spending $85 on a palette can be hard to justify. I do consider shu uemura to be “up there” on the beauty ladder so owning a...
Make Up For Ever Midnight Glow Palette

1 review

I have to admit that I was not expecting the shadows to be that difficult to work with. The formula was a bit too hard for my liking to use as a main eye shadow and losing pigmentation was a bit of a disappointment. I did like the colours that were chosen to create the palette...