Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1241-1260 of 1574

e.l.f. Cosmetics Studio Beauty School 32 Piece Eye Shadow Palette

5 reviews

I'm so undecided about this product. I feel like all the colours are so neutral that they are almost too neutral. It's too the point I feel like you my as well just not wear everyshadow at all. Most of the colours are not even remotely noticeable when wearing it. Not a whole...
QUO double face palette

1 review

Got this for a gift for my birthday. it comes with 5 lip glosses, 2 blushes and 6 eyeshadows aside it being a good affordable palette, the eyeshadow shades aren't very wearable for me, not my go to colours. I LOVE THE BLUSHES and the lip glosses are alright
Marcelle Eye Shadow Quad

3 reviews

Love the way it is easy to apply the colors, they go on smoothly and blend very well! They have just a little sparkle to them, not much but just enought to give a pop to your eyes.
Wet N Wild Perfect Pair Eye Wand Eyeshadow

2 reviews

I love this product, but you can rarely find it anymore in my area. It was available at Dollar Stores also. I loved to buy it in blue, black and plum. It worked great.
NYC Sparkle Eye Dust

2 reviews

I personally hated this product. I bought it because I was away and had no makeup and this was cheap and looked fun. The wand does not hold the color so when you open it, it goes everywhere. The color does not stay on nice and smooth but rather smears everywhere. I bought it one...
Physicians Formula Nude Palette

5 reviews

I love this eyeshadow for everyday wear. It doesn’t irritate my eyes at all. I love the colours and it stays on a long time. I can’t wait to try more colours.
NARS Eyeshadow Duo

3 reviews

I love Nars I never get disappointed with there products so when I tried this I wasn’t disappointed it’s easily blended it’s very neutral for every day looks great and lasts all day
Clinique Eye Shadow in Plum Potion

4 reviews

I got this when I was buying a foundation and it was on half price. Just wow! Love it !! Will definitely buy again. The only downside is it comes in small quantity and a bit pricey
NYX glam shadow

2 reviews

I received this in an Ipsy bag. I thought I'd like it, but the shadow was not a very pigmented formula. I use it for adding to a color but not alone
Urban Decay Fun Palette

1 review

I got a REALLY awesome deal on this palette today and I am HEAD OVER HEELS LADIES!!! This Palette is GORGEOUS! It comes in a little case with an awesome little design, It has a magnet holding it in the case which is functional and fabulous! The shadow is BRIGHT and BEAUTIFUL!...
essence Stays No Matter What Eye Pencil and Shadow

2 reviews

I got this colour in Twinkling Turqouise. Wore it to work and it did indeed stay put. Love this!
NYC Individual Eyes Green Eyes

1 review

I love this palette because it has the labels of what the product can/is made for. So it's perfect for beginners or people who don't know all that much about makeup. So they make it super easy for anyone & it's perfect for on-the-go because the pallet comes with the primer...
NYX Be Fierce Palette

1 review

I really like a lot of NYX products but I am not impressed with this one. Although I like how travel friendly it is I am on the fence about the quality. The glosses and blushes are nice but the shadows are really chalky and the colour pay off isn't great. Overall, a good...
CoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow

5 reviews

Covergirl bombshell shineshadow are creams shadows that have a smooth consistency almost like a mousse. they are so easy to apply and they blend beautifully. the colors are buildable too. they can also act as a base for eyeshadows. highly recommand
Bonne bell eyeplayset

1 review

I don't use bonne bell products much anymore, except these. This brand was one of the only ones I used as a pre-teen, as I was only able to wear lip balm/gloss. I always loved the flavors too. I also love the fact that this brand does not test on animals. This palette consists...
Physicians Formula Eyebrightener Multi-Colored Eyelighter

1 review

I have dark lids and this really brightened up that area. It is multi-colored but doesn't give a ton of color. It is pearlescent and shimmery, and is long lasting. Although I don't care for the brush and use my own applicator, I would recommend if you have dark lids.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Mineral Eye Shadow

13 reviews

Excellent eyeshadow in beautiful colors - the sifter jars hold a lot of product, making this an even better deal. One of the most affordable brands around, ELF has really come a long way in the last 10 years. The mineral shadows are 100% natural and are actually good for your...
Revlon ColorStay Shadowlinks Eyeshadow in Blush Matte

1 review

This eyeshadow is a very cute matte light pink. It is not pigmented at all and barely leaves a trace of color when smudged with a brush or finger. Definitely would not recommend.
CoverGirl Stack-ups Shimmer Dust

1 review

I use this product to blend an expresso eyeshadow in my crease. I've gotten a lot of compliments on the shimmer, it's just enough to make you look ready for a night out but work for day as well
Quo Eyeshadow in "Spring Fling"

2 reviews

I also got this in the sale bin, I don't think it was one of their better series, but they also put out a lot of sets that year, and one had to make way for the next. The greens set from the same release was much better. A couple of the colours are good, but the rest are...