Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1301-1320 of 1574

bh comestics bh pary girl palette

1 review

Bh cosmetics palette is very reasonable price and great quality for gurus to just beginning. I love it!!!
little black book cool edition

1 review

Very sexy eyeshado colors:) wear them during the day
Wet N Wild coloricon single eyeshadow "Panther"

2 reviews

Such a good staple piece and so affordable! I use this to line my eyes and it's a very good quality black black. The packaging is not my favorite, I have trouble opening it all the time! Given the price, definitely worth a try!
Coastal Scents Hot Pots

4 reviews

The Coastal Scents hot pot in the shade 'Brownstone' is the perfect color for my eyebrows! I like it more than some of the higher end products I've used. It also works great as an eyeshadow.
L'Oreal Paris Forever Pink Eyeshadow

1 review

really nice color, but hard to put on
NYX SoHo Glam Palette

1 review

I am so sorry to say that this is by far NYX's worst product. I really wanted to love this item. The colours looked great but so darn chalky. I got this on sale for $12.00 at Rexall and I wish I passed it by. I love a lot of NYX products, just not this one :(
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Shadow Pencil

11 reviews

I have four of these shades and all are just amazing. The best thing about this one is that I can use it daily to my workplace. The colour and texture is very fine and smooth
Wet N Wild coloricon eyeshadow single in "Brulee"

10 reviews

This is such a great single eyeshadow, and I can’t believe it’s less than a dollar. It is so creamy and pigmented. I use it as a base all over my eyes. It cancels everything out.
MAC Cosmetics Eyeshadow in Pink Freeze

10 reviews

I have been using Mac eyeshadow for over 20 years. Most of the time I have used Pink Freeze as my main shade. I love it! I was heartbroken to find out they discontinued it last summer. I went around to several stores buying any stock they had available. Overall, I find that...
Chanel Mystere les 4 ombre eyeshadow palette

2 reviews

After trying multiple products over the years I have reached the conclusion that Chanel cosmetics is a waste of money. At their shadows have zero pigmentation. The fallout of these shadows is just as bad. Lasting power is a joke. Really the only quality about this product is...
COVERGIRL Smokey Shadowblast

32 reviews

It's alright, the colours blend easily on my lids and the format makes it great for travel. It did break off the stick a little and it creased after 6 hours which just meant I blended it out a little with my finger.
Rimmel London Color Rush Quad Eyeshadow

19 reviews

I really love the color and it just needs a slight touch up here and there during an 8 hour day. I will definitely buy this type of eye shadow again. The colours are beautiful and I love this pallet. It was a great price, and I would recommend to others for sure!
Maybelline New York Color Plush Silk Eyeshadow

7 reviews

I really like these eyeshadows for the most part. The color payoff is pretty good, and I think that has to do with how soft the shadows are texture-wise. I do wish that matte shades existed with this kind of consistency. The issue that I have is that the shadows don't last a...
NYX Bohemian Chic Palette

2 reviews

I bought this pallette after reading some very good reviews on NYX Matte eyeshadows. It offers a very wide range of neutrals in an easy to apply, easy to blend formula. There are also a few bright colored shadows in the bottom tray, with the blushes, so you can glam it up a...
MAYBELLINE New York Chic Naturals 10S Vanilla

2 reviews

I like this. It takes some time to figure out how to work it, because its very powdery and a little goes a looong way. I've been experimenting with it and prefer it as a highlight over an eyeshadow. Its very shimmery/metallic so you have to apply with a light hand. I've heard...
Maybelline New York Expertwear Eyeshadow Trio in Impeccable Greys

17 reviews

The perfect formula, everything about this shadow is awesome. Maybelleine killed this product, amazing amazing amazing I cannot recommend it enough!!!!
Hard Candy Shadowholic Eye Crayon

1 review

I have this eye crayon in the colour Camel Back, a champagne type hue, I just got it the other day and since then it has become my go to colour. This is an eyeshadow crayon, waterproof and it promotes itself as lasting 12 hrs. It does live up to this, it's very long lasting and...
Wet N' Wild Coloricon Trio "Sweet as Candy" eyeshadow

6 reviews

This trio and the walking on egg shells one are such an affordable and good eyeshadow! It’s defiantly an under rated product in the drug store and one of my favourites!
Annabelle Cosmetics Loose Eye Shadow Powder

2 reviews

With pretty well any loose powder eyeshadow, you run the risk of having major fallout. These are no exception! There are some really beautiful colours here. In order to utilize them, I find they work best with both an eye primer (one that's fairly tacky so the product will...
MAC Cosmetics Paint Pot in Soft Ochre

14 reviews

I prefer this oncer using an eyeshadow primer or even concealer. All I need is a thin launder and my discolouration is gone. I then set it with a powder and all my other shadows blend perfectly on top