Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1321-1340 of 1574

Sephora Moonshadow Baked Palette

8 reviews

Je vous recommande de l'acheter Une bonne pigmentation comme je le veux. Un maquillage comme des les pro . Heureuse de cette trouvaille Je l'ai utilisé dans plusieurs occasions et même y'a tous les couleurs que vous aurez besoin. Happy 2021!
Cargo Eyeshadow Duo

1 review

I had never heard of Cargo Eyeshadow until I received it in a monthly sample box. I received "Sausalito" Which is a nude pink on one side and a copper on the other. This formula is by far the smoothest/ silkiest eyeshadow I have ever used. The colours are buildable so you can...
Wet 'N Wild Walking On Eggshells

9 reviews

I used to use the original Walking on Eggshells trio so I was super happy to see it return as a quad. The shades are the perfect mix for a neutral, everyday eye look. The pink colour is very flattering on pale skin and blends out into a soft champagne colour. I’ve completely...
NYX Trio Eyeshadow

7 reviews

Great colour saturation and it would be hard to find a better trio for the price.
L.A. Colors 5 Color Metallic Eyeshadow

7 reviews

I would buy this product again. I love the company and how they keep up on the makeup trends. I will always be a avid L.A. Colors girl! The eye shadow will stay all on day and night, if you are like me a forget to wash makeup off after a long day.
Urban Decay Urbanglow Cream Highlight

3 reviews

Gorgeous highlight! I use it all the time, and it doesn't fade throughout the day!
Smashbox Limitless 15 Hour Wear Cream Shadow

2 reviews

Lasts forever, so great, I love the colours.
Sephora Primal Instincts palette

1 review

I was swatching different eyeshadows in Sephora and I came across this amazing pallet it has colors that are amazing and last a long time. The thing that made me love it i the store was the pigment I the shadows it is strong and natural. xoxo sammie
Quo On The Beach Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

The Quo - On The Beach eyeshadow palette has 10 coordinating neutral shades which are perfect for the summer! I like how not all the shadows were shimmery to give me some choice if I didn't want shimmer. The colors looked great on my skin tone and are neutral enough to...
Maybelline Eye Studio Cream Eye Shadow

11 reviews

love it. I love the way the colors just stood out of my eyes. would definable recommend this product to a friend and will for sure use it again in the future!!
L'Oreal Paris The One Sweep Eye Shadow

13 reviews

This surprisingly worked pretty well for me. I think this works better if you have flatter eyelids in general, or are a monolidder. Unlike other l'oreal shadows, I was somewhat surprised at the lack of pigmentation in these shades. I was also rather disappointed at the amount of...
Victoria's Secret Brilliant Shimmer Shadow

1 review

I love love love everything about this shadow. The way it looks, the shimmer, the colors, and the staying power. The sad news is I think VS is discontinuing it so I bought all I could get a hold of during the last semi annual sale. I hope if you find some during the next sale...
Maybelline New York Expertwear Eye Shadow Quad in Chai Latte

10 reviews

I love the whole line of Maybelline New York Expertwear Eye Shadow Quads. They look great, easy to apply and stay put! They are a great value for money! very vivid colours and i am away happy with the results! the instructions are also easy to follow for those of us who don't...
Hard Candy Eye Duo

11 reviews

The Eye Duo I bought is a baked eyeshadow in nude colors. It looked gorgeous in the store but I've now grown to hate (yes hate) Hard Candy products. It takes so many coats of eyeshadow to get a good pigment, it's money thrown in the garbage. When you do get enough pigment, it's...
Sephora Hot Hues Baked Shadows

1 review

Formula: The majority of the shadows are easy to blend but a couple were a bit dry to work with. Other than that the colors are well pigmented and a fabulous variety of plum hued colors. A couple have shimmer to them but not chunks of glitter which is good but they do have...
NYX Dark Shadows Limited Edition Palette

1 review

Formula: I don't think I own too many NYX shadows so it was pleasantly surprising to discover how richly pigmented the formula is in this set. They are lush and vibrant and most of all NO GLITTER! Although some shades have sheen and shimmer it is quite unobtrusive and women of...
Estee Lauder Pure Color Gelée Powder EyeShadow

4 reviews

Pure Color Gelee Powder Eye Shadow is a very clever innovative eye shadow by Estee Lauder. Designed to offer you maximum impact eye shadow colour, these little eye shadow compacts come in six stunning limited edition shades which can be worn as is when applied dry or worn wet...
BH Cosmetics 120 Eyeshadow Palette

13 reviews

At first I thought the colors were not very pigmented but as I learned more about eyeshadow I tried again with a lighter concealer for the primer and it really did make a difference. The colors popped out so much more it was crazy. So now I’m trying to start using this palette...
essence Stay All Day Long Lasting Eye Shadow

5 reviews

Let me be clear -- I do think that the price is very good ($2.99), but I felt I had to lower my star rating on this review in order to get my point across here. I bought this shadow in number 18. I have already opined about how I hate Essence for not having outer packaging to...
Maybelline New York Eye Shadow Expert Wear Natural Smokes

1 review

This eye shadow lasts over 12 hours. Makes your eyes stand out and does not feel heavy. Very good quality. I love how the 4 colours blend well together.