Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1341-1360 of 1574

e.l.f. Cosmetics Beauty Encyclopedia Basic Eye Editon

4 reviews

All these eyeshadows are pigmented! I also really like the cream shadows, as a little bit of the cream shadow is great as an eyelid primer. The basic eye edition is great for those who like warmer more purple shades with some neutral shades. I also really like how there are...
Too Faced Naked Eye Soft & Sexy Eye Shadow Collection

2 reviews

J'adore ce produit. Il est devenu mon indispensable. Je l utilisé au quotidien. Je n'ai jamais été déçu de ces produits. Bonne qualité, bonne tenue. Je le recommande
Revlon Sable Eyeshadow

1 review

I actually got this one at a warehouse sale so I'm not sure how much it would retail for but I'm sure it's cheap since it's only one shadow. It's extremely pigmented and it's just a really nice brown. You can build it up to make it more deeper although I find it can have a lot...
Cargo Eyeshadow Single

2 reviews

La texture est douce et fine, la couleur intense est présente toute la journée, il ne tombe pas dans les yeux, est facile à appliquer... C'est un gagnant !
Diego Dalla Palma Snow White And Huntsman Palette

1 review

Formula: The eye shadows are well pigmented and silky although two feel a bit chalkier like the fairest and destiny shade which are the two lightest. I remedied that with mixing medium and a heavier application. I also recommended using primer underneath for a more dramatic pop...
Annabelle Cosmetics Tic Tac Trio Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

This is a decent palette. I have to thank ChickAdvisor for giving me this as a prize for one of their contests. I love using the lighter/medium shades in this palette as they are buildable and really pretty colors. The darker colors on the other hand are a little lackluster to...
e.l.f. 32 Piece Eyeshadow Palette

11 reviews

This is an amazing eye shadow palette. The colors are very beautiful and pigmented. This palette has every type of shade in it. Perfect for any occasion. I love the packaging. It is a very big palette. This is definitely worth having in your collection.
L'Oreal Colour Fresco Eye Shadow Creme-Crushed Blush

2 reviews

All I can say is love this product. Goes on amazingly.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Brightening Eye Color in Butternut

3 reviews

I think this is a great eyeshadow quad, it is so inexpensive, yet the color payoff is great. I do find that these colors are not particularly long lasting and are somewhat powdery, but eyeshadow primer seems to counter this. I really like the butternut quad especially as it is...
Maybelline New York Dream Mousse Shadow

13 reviews

I like how this product dries down and you can even pressed pigments into it while it's still moist love love love this product. I wish I had them all. first time user. Not a bad buy for the dollar. If you can catch them on sale it's even better. Also I like how this product...
NARS Soft Touch Shadow Pencil

4 reviews

I LOVE this shadow pencil and I am so sad that it was discontinued. I have been using the sparkly black (can't remember the name) since receiving a free sample at Sephora about 8 years ago. I haven't gone back since. It's perfect as a liner or eye shadow and the added shimmer...
Sugarpill Love

2 reviews

I adore Sugar pill products! They send you the cutest boxes & package everything perfectly in tissue paper. & add in stickers & a free sample of loose shadows how could one not love them. Love+ is one of the most amazing red eye shadows on the market. I love using this eye...
Sephora Pantone Universe Shades of Nature Eye Shadow Palette

2 reviews

Patchy, not pigmented at all very dry chalky. Not black girl friendly, and I’m not even that dark. What a shame but love everything else from the Sephora line.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Beauty Book Smoky Eye Edition

6 reviews

Most of these eyeshadows are pretty pigmented, which works well for a smokey look. But a couple of the shades are less pigmented, and these tend to be the matte ones. I do think a primer is necessary for this, as a couple shades are also on the powdery side. The included...
Forever 21 Smokey Eye Shadow Palette

2 reviews

I bought this item in an online order for the purpose of bringing my total up to the minimum amount of money required to qualify me for free shipping. I didn't quite know what to expect, as I had never bought make-up from a clothing brand store in the past. as a person who likes...
stila cosmetics Barbie Loves Stila Eye Shadow Palette

2 reviews

This eyeshadow palette is amazing! I love that it is long lasting. It does not cause any creasing. I don't need a primer (which saves a lot of time) and the colours are easy to blend. Absolutely love the colours.
Sally Girl Eyeshadow

6 reviews

I don't much like the color used here in the picture, but I have a purple one, brown, and silver. These little eye shadows can be found at sally's and they're under 5 dollars a piece. I have been using this stuff for years due to the fact that the pigment in this stuff is WAY...
Lorac Starry-Eyed Baked Eyeshadow

3 reviews

I so miss this trio from LORAC!!!! It was one of the first things I ever bought at #Sephora when it first came to #Canada. Truth be told; I was intimidated by the store initially - a girlfriend took me by the hand and was my introduction to that whole new world that opened up :)...
NARS Eye Shadow in Cancan

1 review

I absolutely love this color. It's a vibrant purple that goes on great. It last all day and does not smudge or crease. I find myself using this color lightly in the daytime and applying a bit more to achieve a more vibrant color.
NARS Single Eyeshadow

7 reviews

I've been really into bright pops of color lately. I wanted to keep my makeup collection small, so the NARS eyeshadow in Matcha is an amazing addition. I used my pc optimum points so the price didn't hurt me too much! I am extremely impressed that the green actually shows up on...